TRE2019-00054 City of Tigard, Oregon • 13125 SW Hall Blvd. • Tigard, OR 97223
TIGARD
10/24/2019
MCALISTER, RANDY & LAURIE B
15410 SW EMPIRE TER
TIGARD, OR 97224
Re: Tree Removal Permit Record Number: TRE2019-00054
Dear MCALISTER, RANDY & LAURIE B:
On 10/24/2019 you submitted an application for tree removal at 15410 SW EMPIRE
TER. Your application specified that:
1 Callery Pear
is/are proposed for removal. Based on the information supplied on your application,
this is a simple tree removal permit request.
City staff has reviewed your application and based on the relevant approval criteria in
the Urban Forestry Manual, your application has been:
Street Tree Replacement Required
Approved with conditions:
The applicant shall plant a replacement tree for each tree removed in accordance
with the Street Tree Planting Standards in Section 2, part 1 of the Urban Forestry
Manual. Existing trees may be considered as replacement trees if they meet all
applicable species, size, condition and location requirements in Section 2, part 1
and were not already required to be planted or preserved by the Tigard Municipal
Code.
This decision is final and valid for a period of up to one year after issuance unless
otherwise specified. Nothing prevents you from submitting another tree permit
application if the conditions and circumstances surrounding this removal have
changed.
If you have any questions, please contact us at arborist@tigard-or.gov or
503-718-2421. Please be sure to reference record number- TRE2019-00054.
Best regards,
C: '> L - /fe:/ _—
Community Planning Division
City of Tigard
RECEIVED
City ofTigard I COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT OCT 2 4 2019
INs ' Tree Removal Permit Application CITY OF TIGARD
PLANNING/ENGINEERING
T (CARD Soh"citud de Permisojara RemoverArboles
PROPERTY ADDRESS I DIRECCION DE LA PROPIEDAD������� � � � �-- REQUIRED SUBMITTAL
Address (Direction): L_.Ll1J '1 Jf�)1¢�4YZ' _ 1 .� ELEMENTS
APPLICANT I SOLICI"I'AN'I'E / /1!k;,Oa/ li REQUISITOS PARA APLICAR
(N ) /I( /I her D Owner'snaion Signature/Written
Name ombre: z./.��/,S`�,/ r -. I G', Authorization
Address (Direccidn): 6 1 0 Ll� al_i,/,/,,re i 0/117//72 / Firma del duefo/Autoritiacion por
v( 'e / <l / '�r'�/ e,rc7ito
Phjone l): I O 7- `:-.) 0 .) m
/ Eil:/Jt111�6�•=
TREE REMOVAL PERMIT APPLICATION
II. COMPLEX REVIEW PROCESS (check applicable reason and provide brief proposal summary)
PROCESO DE REVISION COMP.FfO(Marque et motive ap/icabley de nna explicadon breve)
❑ Blocking views or solar access ❑ Undesirable species ❑ Other (explain below)
(Bloqueo de vista o acceso solar) (Especie no deseada) Otro (eap/igne debajo)
Please leave blank for staff I Dejar en Nancy pares el personal
THE APPLICANT SHALL CERTIFY THAT: EL SOLICITANTE CERTIFICA QUE:
• The above request does not violate any deed restrictions • La solicited anterior no viola ninguna restriction de las
that may be attached to or imposed upon the subject e.rcdturas de la prnpiedad que pueda ser conectada a o impuesta
property. sobre la pivpiedad en euestion.
• If the application is granted,the applicant will exercise the • Si/a solicitud es concedida, el solicitante eercerci los derechos
rights granted in accordance with the terms and subject to concedidos de acuerdo con los terminosy srjeto a las conditioner),
all the conditions and limitations of the approval. limitations de la aprobacion.
• All of the above statements and the statements in the plot • Todas las declarations anterioresy las declarations en el
plan,attachments,and exhibits transmitted herewith,are e vquis, los documento.r adjuntos,y muestras trasmitidas,son
true;and the applicants so acknowledge that any permit verdaderas,y los solicitantes asi reconocen que cualquierpermiso
issued,based on this application,and may be revoked if it is concedido, basado en esta so/icitud,puede ser revocado si se
found that any such statements are false. encuentra que alguna de estas a Irraciones es falsa.
• The applicant has read the entire contents of the • El solicitante ha le/do todo el concenido de/a aplicacion,
application,including the policies and criteria,and int/uyendo las politicasy criteriosy comprende los requuitos para
understands the requirements for approving or denying the
amber,-o rregar/a solicrtud
application.
SIGNATURES of each owner of the subject property required.
FIRMAS de Cada dueiio de la propiedad e .cuestion requeridas.
III . . ., , . .' 21 4 ti # _ 4
ki ) z'3/ 1
,.. 1_ts - ( i,'na``( r n e Print name (Nombre) /\ Date (Fecba)
„iiiii Aratirallaillial .c.--- 1N.4.-kS3-1 VI\c —%`‘'rS12.--- /
Owner's signaeur• (Firma del duerio) Print name (Nombre) Date111
cba)
Owner's signature (Firma del duerlo) Print name (Nombre) Date (Fecha)
Authorized agent's signature Print name (Nombre) Date (Fecha)
(Firma de agente autorkado)
•
City ofTigard • 13125 SW Hall Blvd. • Tigard,Oregon 97223 • www.tigard-or.gov • 503-718-2421 • Page 4 of 4
4 it) kyr
G'11�i-'e rl 'tar
r
,
CERTIFIED , , Licensed*Bonded*Insured
ARBOR'S!' , " CCB#199579
•
ISA
EUERGREEN
IR,EJEISERV/CES
Diane Gurley
Cell:(971)227-5199
15532 SW Pacific Hwy Office:(503)625-4595
PMB#304 Diane@evergreenTSL.com
Tigard,OR 97224
/ - /G _ Li.) L—h-i,f /rc� 1'r..N
0
, 0). I( Lki ....-- 1 . ---.),
I X - -1rvi,i-e,riri) tffr
,, r ..
.,. , _ ,
____
s , 1
. _ill
to
______ _ _ _ _
CERTWwD Licensed"Bonded*Insured
ARBORIST
4 %a
77/A:41CC81!199579
ISA
EVERWEF
TREE SERVICES •
Diane Gurley ''' ;'° c ' '. ^-4 Cell:(971)227-5199
15532 SW Pacific Hwy '" '
Office:(503)625-4595 •
PMBtf304 Diane@evergreenTSL.com
Tigard,OR 97224
Lina Smith
From: diane gurley <diane@evergreentsl.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 24, 2019 1:01 PM
To: Lina Smith
Subject: Re: Tree removal permit for Laurie McAlister at 15410 SW Empire Terrace
Caution! This message was sent from outside your organization. Allow sender I Block sender
Thank you for the call. Yes the flowering pear is in decline due to storm damage last year. The top 20 ft of the
tree broke off, I reccomend removal.
On Thu, Oct 24, 2019, 12:58 PM Lina Smith < LinaCS@tigard-or.gov wrote:
Hi Diane,
Thanks for talking to me on the phone about this one. As we discussed on the phone, you find that this
tree is "in an advanced state of decline." Please hit "reply all" to this e-mail, explain your findings for this
tree, and whether or not you recommend removal. Since you are Mrs. McAlister's arborist, we need
something from you, in writing, that confirms this information. Attached is a copy of the application Mrs.
McAlister submitted to us, for reference.
Thank you,
Lina Smith
Assistant Planner
City of Tigard I Community Development
13125 SW Hall Blvd.Tigard,OR 97223
E-mail: LinaCSna,tigard-or.gov
From: Laurie McAlister<Imcalister@ttsd.k12.or.us>
Sent:Thursday, October 24, 2019 12:35 PM
To:#CD PoD<CDPoD@tigard-or.gov>
Subject: Fwd:
1
Please find attached our request for tree removal at 15410 SW Empire Terrace 97224
Best -LM
Laurie B. McAlister
Early Learning Center Director
Pregnant & Parenting Student Services
Creekside Community High School/TTSD
8040 SW Durham Rd. Tigard OR 97224
' 503*431*5824 Office
503*431*4590 FAX
Forwarded message
From: <DUR-Kyocera4002i@ttsd.k12.or.us>
Date: Thu, Oct 24, 2019 at 12:30 PM
Subject:
To: < Imcalister@ttsd.k12.or.us>
TASKaIfa 4002i
[00:17:c8:4c:b1:21]
DISCLAIMER: E-mails sent or received by City of Tigard employees are subject to public record laws. If requested, e-
mail may be disclosed to another party unless exempt from disclosure under Oregon Public Records Law. E-mails are
retained by the City of Tigard in compliance with the Oregon Administrative Rules "City General Records Retention
Schedule."
2
reupie c11JV dJN
Do you get fruit from a flowering pear tree?
How big does a flowering pear tree get?
t
-1k Ultimately it can grow to a height of 30 to 40 feet and about one-third as wide.
Flowering pear has a relatively short lifespan of 15 to 25 years, many flowering pear
trees live only 15 to 20 years because of inherent problems.
What Is the Average Lifespan of a Flowering Pear Tree? ( Home ...
https://homeguides.sfgate.corn > average-lifespan-flowering-pear-tree-60463
Search for: How big does a flowering pear tree get?
How long does it take a flowering pear tree to grow?
five to seven years
Time Frame
Pears typically produce the first fruits three years after planting,although they won't
produce a full crop for five to seven years. Dwarf trees usually produce fruit a bit
earlier than standard-size trees, as do Asian pears (Pyrus serotina L.).
How Long Does It Take to Grow Pears? I Home Guides I SF Gate
https://homeguides.sfgate.com > long-grow-pears-79479
Search for: How long does it take a flowering pear tree to grow?
Are flowering pear trees messy?
Are flowering pear tree roots invasive?
Why is my pear tree not flowering?
Why Bradford pears are the worst tree?
Do pear trees grow fast? • -
How tall should a pear tree be?
rw.google.com/search?q=flowering+pear+tree&oq=flowering+pear&aqs=chrome.0.0j69i57j014.6927j0j8&sourceid
--,•,, • •• 1
-. .. .u.!...-'• ' -
'Io
.. -
. .,,
, . .
t, ,te•:.,,,. —
'.•,• ! •
;
'i•
1
„, .1.A-a 1., ...... . _ •
• .•,I.. , .
tj4
,. ..
-.cue
+ •. ., "--
•• , .
„.,.,
• AI•! !',.
It
'. . . . ' '. 4 ... s 4 c,.:...,11 f - . •• ,
. 4-:-.• • w.. ,
i 4 11
"K-. ":14 -.4.; '- --4;-',.- -;si. - .,...4..,--.: •;it..""--,-, , .•- - • 1 --.:, •
..: .
)•'
,:,.. ,, .*. „. ,.:s. :.t.• . -• ,
,...„,.
1.
• ....ai• ,'....V- '
''': %-- — .... •..14.:.k., '..., . p : 1”: :- :' ;if' '', .. 1.--- . .4 if 1110'.'4)Iti,.. 1 •.4 '- .. -
i •Vt' f 4;
-'• ". .'---- '-..-,-- . ' , 1.:13"- .. ..,'.... .. •--) ;• . ..---...'s •.' .4,'4 ,4--'1'•;tr"...-*., i-. ...: .:-4. ..
, , . •
•--4.--- -.‘..,-,---,..7-.tts.jk••' -,*• - :s1-:...,. ,,,t,,.. , ,:.!,... 1 ,:(4fir. •s;,.. '' .•- , • v•'..•'„•,11P .. ?T.'. wi •• . •
.• — • ' -.• '..W.-:-.;;;-""... ••-•At:. ..".-''''''-,, , ...,..', . i ../...: ' r.4.-. ....ik',.•.... -• . •. ,, •'•"- •f'..t, ...f•• , :•'. ;.. .,
, .', ., , 4. , . : ' .:•• • ,''.4..14 'N k ' i i.1.,1 1
1 ....- -. -,'-• • -- -'4k, :: .-.;;;;•4ss,',.:",,." ' ..:••:• ‘,-•.„• - .. !,,.ti,c,,•.,...e... :.'1.7 e.,,• . ....•• ..'.. .,, • ..s .-.•
f •
••• .4. 't ' 1
- . .., '`.., . . .. ... • . ....f.;', ., . •. .. i .f..4.::: :': Y.: -: ' ':‘,- ...t'-• .,. •' :,. . - .: ,--':"&":. i 4 1 k: i * 1
,. . ,. ,-..._ : •.. . . ',.. -....-'', .,. - '' , -.- .. :., -• t . ' -...4.
4... •r
•7,;t: or f.. . .: --. -,.- _. • . -',.'-....''''• „..••,•.... C.:• •. • ''' •' '... : ,"r.•._ ;, •_ . •:- '.. ...'• • ,..• ..- -..' i ,
- •• ..
.t.
..::. '.-.' •7'-' ",;'!,-.•-' .,• Nay... -.- ,:',. L''''-z:.'.' ••'44' .•(. .••••• s'..•1`Zw.- ,..... • •
. . .
• ., • ' ' .....1
.. . .
.• •.. 1.•;;'5..i.-..„•:;.''..•;.....;:„ '2.'4,..•• :',r.: . .‘' •,..ilc' .-''••.....4-..,!-..i: .•
. .
... ,... ,
'-'4. : . - L'-••••;''.A.-... '..:iFt ......` ...... ''- • ..*• '7.•-s•''' •4 . ." 4. .„, '. • . . ...... -•
,•••••
. • a,..,. 1
-'-°-}Y.741,1,1',' • - . .:..4r4:---!4•••-;:a.. .-- . '4.•-• - . -' '''':!.-'.‘-. 44.'-•%t ;•.7 .;.: '..:'-• ' - • '-'''- ..''. . - •i*&.-; I. ' .4
- 4
' ...-ifY"...::::.ti ...\ • ---i.ii-1. : .....:-.....----.74
•.. . . '• '- ' - • .t.' /' ,
'•--r.1,-,--;':,."...--....-..--- ..:.-. Pr-; - .;,•-••--,...•-_-:- - • '". '••••-,.-hor.....;••, ,-...L., .._
- •-"r''' -..-'.`,::-;,14''..; ,,,:..A60:,-._ , .."'.1i:i•• ":-;*,-•;•;..z-..is;,.r.40..,--wars.....4.,.. ..-- . . •• ,. z. ,,
.,. .7
t-A14-.1-;.-?,*•;-.-'..2-.•4';-;•F-1.;t::,....:it--,......`..'„,..1.4..;;."' ..1,.,i..."....' ;:,-.........*:•.-t‘.1,.:;,,.,::„.:::;:,:...,...:54,..::7.;:, '
.
...,%i...,...,..,.. ,, ,..,..;-sp..0_ ., , . 10.....,....4--•. :. ;;410t.. ....„;.1:,1r,...a...4,...,4 . ..., ,- , ......dleF, ...- . .. .......4....v.,:i...,.4,-:,i'....,!..." •,„...;,-..**,,
, ".•`` :ni-ts ='` • _ ;,..' ',- ' .'‘, 'kV-4...." 7-0:-4,1-',. : "'`' ''k7.• • •;':•.4•-•
or''.•-.-..4"4i;"-;" 41.11141,:*:'.*::';i'i ..• i's .:• •
.. ..
• - •
. ... rKA!•:iir'' 'Itl, :itt,.. .:, 4, 1•*. ;i'L•. . i •
10. .
. t
••
, ._
,... - . •
tjr
' illpt",...i... . •'; - LI
Ilk
„ ••'..s. ••• .. • ..'.',. ' ' . '• if.i • '4 : ' ‘..r"*.•,*'•'.."..71-c:.:.•
$
I ;•.4:',,' 4 '. •k.1.•.i?";%t . . '-'?:,i;.1„ ,''''';.;,...•:' .'": , r' ' • i - N I -
. .
. .... ,„ ,, ,. • ''.• ‘Z,,04-,;.
.e ' • •
•.........,„ . . . •
,. r•
.... . ..
,
.. ..-i,...."-• ,.,,.•,- ••.. .., ,,,,,, ,.•-...-,•,- .... ••.;•• ,
, .
• - .... •• -4.• . : ,t- .:.. ... , 4 --. 1 ., ,,,,T .,. . •-•,.
‘ .
..s .
••..,...v, -,,,__ i•il,i. ,.,t-- •••,7;d-. 7 I ' . - ?.`.. .,;) " ,,,,,s'c—'I. • '..
''' -'-=.' - -•' .'?::'r -.''''..'"...`'',)‘•''''...."'A,',....' v..•^4P s',,,....414',•.' . ....•'`•,•,'-. ' ' A.. .4.;','.,-,•!- -.........e
..,.,. , ..." ,-..!: .„‘ : •,:,: -:%,.:•`••••?• .4.,-;?..--... -. ,s. •- , •,''..,,, ,'.- ;,
4,......
-4-, •,-..-. .., .
.••••••
........,-- ,- •, " :, -
.,.. .,. ...-...-tc .,;.I. :..,, .,!••.. • , _..._
..._______
. .
-
:".''Z•••;„„&„, ' /,--7. ..1.,. .. :''i•7. .:4-1.;:i$ '-` ,
ItiT''''• ... .,4 , . ,-....,.. - ,,,- . - ..- ,t,
•,..',4' - .,t•, '• ..i "-.. • ..;. ; ' • ' 4..-'••
.. ‘..,,,-; ; ;.:,:!...„.-...,i,-..i.:," .{.:', --,/ • •-- ../
A . '•' .
i h•—'•
IL a ii
*ae.ihrillmittio.: 1.1"41411.46:-' ''AriVr<7. '1411:::::1167 111.".. 'll-1:11-7
..0 i .
OW
•
16 I
a ..114s..1 :
l i :
�Ir.
„,4 (.7., .p.,...1...
SI
.42
N%....1 ‘,170-.. :)41
:.,,,,,1 7...:411-41111‘6
:j:N.4 .44 'n.
\,.. ........ . , ... a
.,,t .4).‘
1 (1 f , t� C►, ,.. ,„+ ,.
4 } L
- } ti.4
i' 1,x. 'i
AL.. .),
i-,-
�
•
-
;`r1
m - „,a y rig .
�`h r .• ,la- a x`4'k
0),* /ill
. lk f . i ' ,.
It Oil 4
•
f
dk
11111 ill ilik
VII 1
$ 11„, . „gyp,. rcaA .. - *zx. x:- i
)i 4100.411P fl
4,
+ .+ .,
l
-- '
.s. s
of
>H
i
72
PI1711#4
irY • „
x-
074; .
1
" ' It
\.: . . ......a •ift„ 9
s '4 t• 1/40. ,- g •• 4, _ k r tr"-
ji Zir JIA
► 1 i • /, ,`_
.164, . 'I a •.'t 40 w y i a
li
lib - /5; b. - •**,* -.7 i 4 4' , *4 '.' ot '' '
* 0 Va ... \ %
lik s"
1111'... : _.‘,. 1„ -Ns
.., .. i .
"Il
iu! t ".:7101.).1. 4..#7.. . ,• �
,„,-11, .
:c..„ _2,11, , .:` ,s
i...IIIIP A, • - t.,
� ti 4,,,,ka `' -f 1 a ., arm
t.
tr
• 41
t •
1 �ti�.t1� -, •, ' ' • ' —1i"
4t; lik, 134
I%.Z*b°•14 %. `',,. g ' 4. tili*e"- , 4.-',FAT,Vt.
X" bt410,_; --,?Zsrek , , „
, Th* .,. t
% a , "'
�� 1
.l. i a 41
r ��,a ,`
A
h�}
r
�y
" . -,�•''; . . " f , L • ° +±
yy�
'pyx, g ~
d _
f ,,,. ` rte' Y /,..,, }
. .••• '' ' 9$ .,%, 4, ,• .6
t
f
_ _ .
�Pr _ ,, , . 0 ' � `
:.
,„ .- ,. . , ...- , ,..)... • .
. .
, .., -,„„,,,,... .
- : , no A • • I '
'''' - ar ' JPIIhnitli a
, . * - '' :' .6. A ' 1114"7: A t- t ,.. a
rN'Ir ��
. .. ,, .
• r r' .,' •. tet ..,�". -.a.,. •f.
r:-.::n**.ill'I...E.'
a • t 1 . lit-:11.,..k.,'::
# :..
:1 1::I I
e fi`
, 1:" ..r.i.. ;Gli'
•:4.1.T.1 r:4 I I I:arll 4 I 1:40::A f''''-'1:t:400-1'.r 0:*:'4:I.'.
:l''I
:41:''ILI'1.400'1 il:
ar:7...1.:1 111‘'17. 4.:74.":':111#1.It'''':
.' • L*( :..y , • `7+ `1 '!. .'":
tt.. iliTitz‘1...-717:,,,.';:a.". .
11.11
VP 411 ..$ n S.. if
r, ....i0t-
f. PA, 11 , I 4r* t. ' IC i 111) °
!
4A
rr 1•"' 1 ` , �j �) • , , ,,Ar.E , t
I
..- tg ,
.. ,10/;/ ,
,......, ., ,
..t .f, . ,
, .. . .
.+ s' Alklgibqt;
r`
., fair OP' ‘
p
r \lirOplikr- '
rr