CCDA Minutes - 04/05/2016 Cito f Tigard
Tigard City Council/CCDA Meeting Minutes
r April 5, 2016
1. CCDA& CITY COUNCIL BUSINESS MEETING—April 5,2016
A. Chair Cook called to order the Tigard City Center Development Agency and the City
Council at 6:30 p.m.
B. City Recorder Lager called the roll:
Present Absent
Chair Cook x
Director Goodhouse x
Director Henderson x
Director Snider x
Director Woodard x
C. Chair Cook asked everyone to stand and join him in the Pledge of Allegiance.
D. Chair Cook called to Council and Staff for Non-Agenda Items - None.
CITY CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
2. APPROVE CITY CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES
1.
• October 6,2015
• December 1, 2015
• March 1, 2016
Director Woodard motioned to approve the CCDA minutes and Director Snider seconded the
motion. All voted in favor.
Yes No
Chair Cook x
Director Goodhouse x
Director Henderson (Absent)
Director Snider x
Director Woodard x
TIGARD CITY COUNCIL/CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES—APRIL 5,2016
City of Tigard 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 www.tigard-or.gov Page 1 of 6
3. DOWNTOWN BUSINESS SPOTLIGHT PRESENTATION FROM JUDY HOARFROST,
OWNER OF PADDLE PALACE TABLE TENNIS
Redevelopment Manager Farrelly introduced Judy Hoarfrost,owner of Paddle Palace in downtown
Tigard. He said this will be the first in a regular series focusing on downtown businesses. Ms.
Hoarfrost gave a PowerPoint presentation on their mail order table tennis business. She said they
moved to Tigard from downtown Multnomah Village in August into the old Crown Carpet
location because they needed more space. They are suppliers of many equipment brands and sell
everything related to table tennis. She said their products are shipped worldwide and she
appreciates the proximity of their location to the post office.
Ms. Hoarfrost was a member of the US Table Tennis team for ten years and also went to China as
part of the ping pong diplomacy effort. Worldwide, table tennis is the most popular indoor sport
and is second only to soccer as a participation sport. There are physical and mental benefits to
playing table tennis,including helping reverse effects of Alzheimer's,and it is fun. There are many
clubs all over the country and the sport is growing in popularity in the United States.
Ms. Hoarfrost said they have space in their building where they would like to put in a table tennis
club. People walk in everyday and ask where they can play. There are several clubs in Portland but
there is currently nothing available full time in the SW area of Portland. She wants a better place
for families to play and take classes and where women are comfortable and children can be
dropped off to play. No OLCC license is desired. She wants to provide comfortable table tennis
conditions with a viewing balcony for parents or spectators. She said the city considers it an
assembly place so four restrooms are required for women and two for men. More doors are also
required per the code. She said they are seeking managers, coaches and other personnel to help run
the club.
Director Woodard suggested she look into renting space to personal trainers. He said her
connections provide a huge opportunity for tournaments. Chair Cook welcomed her to Tigard and
said this would be good activity to draw people to the downtown.
Director Snider asked what the CCDA can do to help them. Ms. Hoarfrost responded that the
code was strict about the number of restrooms suggested and there is a question about how many
are needed. She expressed concerns about utilizing as much space for play as possible.
CITY COUNCIL
4. CONSIDER APPROVING THE REVISED CITY CENTER COMMISSION BYLAWS
Redevelopment Manager Farrelly said the City Center Advisory Commission (CCAC) discussed
bylaw revisions at their December 2015 and January 2016 meetings. Several items from the city's
standard bylaws template (which was implemented since the original bylaws were adopted) are
recommended for inclusion. The major change is under the composition section. A designated
represented member does not need to be a resident but must be owner of the business or building
in Tigard. A change is recommended because there may be a business such as a bank or a
TIGARD CITY COUNCIL/CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES—APRIL 5,2016
City of Tigard 1 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 1 www.tigard-or.gov Page 2 of 6
property where it is not practical for the owner to be on the CCAC. It could be valuable to have
the input of a local manager interested in participating. Another item is allowing up to two ex
officio members who represent taxing districts or non-resident experts with desired backgrounds
such as architecture. Section 2 is clarified and specifies that when a member does not meet the
requirements they must resign. He said there are also a few other minor housekeeping items. In
February the CCAC recommended approval of these changes.
Mayor Cook said he thought the changes were good. In response to a question about taxing
district participation,Mr. Farrelly said it is important to foster communication especially as we
consider changes or expansion to the urban renewal area. Staff had received a request from
TVF&R about participating in the past.
Councilor Woodard said he liked the idea of having more people but wanted more than two
property owners and preferred it to be only the owners or major decisions makers. He expressed
concern about conflicts of interest for real estate professionals and bankers who might want to do
business with the City of Tigard. City Manager Wine said this is covered in the Code of Conduct
for Board and Committee Members which they are required to sign. Mayor Cook clarified that this
includes ex officio and non-voting members.
Mayor Cook said a future council may not understand what designated representative means.
Councilor Woodard said it should be someone who is actively managing or participating in
management decisions. City Attorney Olsen suggested using the language, "or their designated
management personnel." Council members agreed with that change.
Councilor Woodard moved to approve Resolution No. 16-11,as amended. Council President
Snider seconded the motion.
Mayor Cook asked City Recorder Krager to read the number and title of the resolution.
Resolution No. 16-11—A RESOLUTION AMENDING THE BYLAWS OF THE
CITY CENTER ADVISORY COMMISSION (CCAC), as amended
Yes No
Mayor Cook x
Councilor Goodhouse x
Councilor Henderson (Absent)
Councilor Snider x
Councilor Woodard x
Mayor Cook conducted a vote and the motion passed unanimously.
TIGARD CITY COUNCIL/CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES—APRIL 5,2016
City of Tigard 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 www.tigard-or.gov Page 3 of 6
5. LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER APPROVING AN ORDINANCE TO
AMEND THE TIGARD MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 10:28 AND 10:32 REGARDING
PARKING
a. Open Public Hearing -Mayor Cook opened the public hearing and announced that this is a
legislative public hearing and anyone may testify.
b. City Attorney Olsen read the hearing procedures,a copy of which was at the front of the room.
C. Mayor Cook read a statement about the process for the public hearing.
d. Staff Report: Redevelopment Project Manager Farrelly gave the staff report. He said parking
is a hot topic in the downtown and there are a lot of concerns from businesses and nearby
residential neighborhoods. He hears many complaints about violations of time limited parking.
Tigard's on-street parking regulations are found in Tigard Municipal Code Chapter 10.32
concerns the authority of council to establish traffic controls and Chapter 10.28 lists the time
limited parking zones in the city. Under the current code adding or making changes to any of
these zones requires a legislative public hearing and adoption of an ordinance changing the
TMC. He gave an example of the signs in the parking lot on Burnham that state a two-hour
parking limit but that newer lot is not listed in the code so police could not write tickets. He
said when the Burnham and Ash development is up and running,parking challenges are
anticipated and staff would like to be able to adjust regulations once there are residents and
businesses. Rather than add the Burnham parking lot or any others that develop staff proposes
to streamline the process and change the TMC to delegate authority to establish parking
controls to the city manager.
Mr. Farrelly directed council's attention to a matrix included in the meeting packet that outlines
council parking and street functions that are proposed to be delegated to the city manager. City
manager decisions would be subject to appeal or review by council. Anyone could appeal the
decision to council and any councilor can initiate a review of a decision related to this TMC
chapter.
Parking regulations would be enforced by installing new signs, clearly stating any time limits or
other restrictions. Before setting new time restrictions staff proposes communicating with and
receiving feedback from nearby businesses and residents. Notices will be mailed prior to the
change going into effect. The city manager could delegate to an interdepartmental team that
includes Senior Transportation Engineer McCarthy, Senior Transportation Planner Brown and
Police Captain McDonald. The team would also have oversight on bus stops and crosswalks.
Public Works will oversee traffic signals and base decisions on traffic engineering principles,
recognized traffic standards and professional judgment. He said there is a last-minute change to
Exhibit A proposed by the Police Department: Chapter 10.32.030 clarifies that the police and
fire department have the ability to temporarily create no-parking zones in emergencies.
e. Council questions of staff. None
f. Public Testimony: No one in the audience signed up to speak.
TIGARD CITY COUNCIL/CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES—APRIL 5,2016
City of Tigard 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 www.tigard-or.gov Pa
ge 4 of 6
g. Staff response to testimony: None
h. Mayor Cook closed the public hearing.
i. Council Deliberation:
Councilor Woodard said he looked at it from a citywide vs.urban renewal area aspect and was
concerned that council would not get the opportunity to hear from the business owners. He
recommended not having it apply to downtown businesses or special districts and wanted
council review on La and Lb. He wrote a suggested motion creating this exception.
Council President Snider said he is generally supportive about delegating to the city manager
and staff because council's job is to set overall policy. He asked for the staff's response to
Councilor Woodard's suggestion. Redevelopment Project Manager Farrelly said it makes sense
to be sensitive to stakeholders and businesses and the idea is to get their feedback before
changes are made. All things being equal staff would rather work it out directly though.
Businesses can always appeal to council if they are unsatisfied.
Councilor Woodard referred to a long ago situation when a city department reached out to
business owners regarding parking and created quite a stir. Hard feelings were created and after
ten years relationships are better but it is still remembered. A public process is a good
opportunity to hear the business owners'opinions. He said he did not want to relinquish his
control over parking in the urban renewal area. Council President Snider said one reason for
the change is so the city can react more nimbly to issues because council action takes a long
time.
City Attorney Olsen said any decision staff makes may be appealed to the city council or a city
councilor may initiate a review. Mayor Cook commented that if a business owner disagrees
with a decision they can always ask a council member to bring it up for review. City Attorney
Olsen said technically the code language on review is post-decision. He said it could be changed
so that the city manager or a city councilor may initiate a review of a proposed or final decision
by filing a written request at any time. This language could be section 10.32.016.C. A potential
impact is that it gives less certainty to business owners who have had a particular parking sign
up for a few months.
Councilor Goodhouse said council has much on their agenda and is micromanaging if it is
reviewing every decision. He said he was supportive of delegation. Council President Snider
noted that staff can be proactive and keep council apprised of any controversial decisions that
may be coming to them for appeal.
Councilor Woodard moved to approve Ordinance No. 16-08 with an amendment to
Section 10.32.016.c the city manager or any council member may initiate a review of any
proposed decision or final decision of the city manager by filing a written request at any
time. Council President Snider seconded the motion.
City Recorder Krager read the number and title of the ordinance.
TIGARD CITY COUNCIL/CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES—APRIL 5,2016
City of Tigard 1 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 1 www.tigard-or.gov Page 5 of 6
Ordinance No. 16-08— AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE TIGARD
MUNICIPAL CODE TO UPDATE SECTION 10.32 DELEGATING
CERTAIN POWERS RELATED TO PARKING AND TRAFFIC
CONTROL ON PUBLIC STREETS TO THE CITY MANAGER, as
amended
Mayor Cook asked City Recorder Krager to conduct a roll call vote of council.
Yes No
Mayor Cook x
Councilor Goodhouse x
Councilor Henderson (Absent)
Councilor Snider x
Councilor Woodard x
Ordinance No. 16-08 passed unanimously.
6. NON-AGENDA ITEMS: None
CITY CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
7. EXECUTIVE SESSION: At 7:44 p.m. Chair Cook announced that the Tigard City Center
Development Agency would enter into Executive Session for consultation with legal counsel
regarding real property transactions under ORS 192.660(2)(e). He said the CCDA would adjourn
immediately after the Executive Session from the Red Rock Creek Conference Room.
8. ADJOURNMENT
At 8:13 p.m. Director Snider moved for adjournment. Director Woodard seconded the motion and
all voted in favor.
Yes No
Mayor Cook x
Councilor Goodhouse x
Councilor Henderson (Absent)
Councilor Snider x
Councilor Woodard x
e2a4,�Z d Z, lC
Carol A. Krager,City Recor er
est:
J s nid r, CDA Vice Chair
Dat (P
TIGARD CITY COUNCIL/CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGENCY MINUTES—APRIL 5,2016
City of Tigard 1 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 1 www.tigard-or.gov Page 6 of 6