09/11/2013 - Packet Completeness
Review for Boards,
Commissions and
Committee Records
CITY OF TIGARD
CCAC—City Center advisory Commission
Name of Board, Commission or Committee
September 11,2013
Date of Meeting
C.L. Wiley
Print Name
r
Signature
2/26/2013
Date
0 0 City of Tigard
City Center Advisory Commission Agenda
MEETING DATE: Wednesday, September 11,2013 — 6:30—8:30 p.m.
MEETING LOCATION: Red Rock Creek Conference Room
13125 SW Hall Blvd., Tigard OR 97223
1. Welcome and Introductions...................................................................................................... 6:30—6:35
2. Review/ Approve August Minutes................................................................................. ........ 6:35 — 6:40
3. Non-Agenda Items/ Public Comment....................... ........ . ...................... 6:40—6:45
4. Explore Downtown Tigard Street Fair Report........................................................................ 6:45 — 7:10
Report on street fair and other downtown events
(Debi Mollahan)
5. City Charter Ballot Measure........................................................................................................ 7:10— 7:25
Review issues related to November 5th city Ballot Measure 34-207
(Chair Shearer and Kenny Asher)
6. Tigard Brownfields Partnership Workshops........................................................................... 7:25 — 7:40
Discus workshop plans and hose CCAC wants to participate in October 9` meeting
(Chair Shearer and Sean Farrelly)
7. FY 15-19 Capital Improvement Plan Suggestions.................................................................. 7:40 — 8:00
Discuss and recommend potential new Downtown pr feels.All Downtown GTPproyects will be compiled and
brought to CCAC far ranking in November.
(Sean Farrelly)
8. 3rd Quarter CCAC Goals Update ............................................................................................ 8:00— 8:15
(Sean Farrelly)
9. Liaison Reports........................................................................................ .............. ..................... 8:15 — 8:30
10. Adjourn.......................................................................................................................................... 8:30 p.m.
Upcoming meetings of note:
September 25,Main Street Meeting, Symposium Coffee, 5:00-6:30 PM
October 1,City Center Development Agency Board meeting,Tigard Town Hall,6:30 PM
October 9, Special CCAC Sponsored Brownfields Partnership Workshop,Library Community Room,6:30 PM
October 17,Main Street Meeting,Max's Brewpub, 5:00-6:30 PM
October 23,Brownfields Partnership Workshop,Tigard Area Chamber,2^s Floor, 6:30 PM
November 5, City Center Development Agency Board meeting,Tigard Town Hall,6:30 PM
CITY CENTER ADVISORY COMMISSION AGENDA— September 11, 2013
City of Tigard 1 13125 SW Hall Blvd.,Tigard, OR 97223 1 503-639-4171 1 www.tigard-or.gov I Page 1 of 2
City Center Advisory Commission
e
Meeting Minutes
Date of Meeting: Wednesday, September 11, 2013
Location: Red Rock Creek Conference Room
Called to order by: Chair Elise Shearer
Time Started: 6:31 pm
Time Ended: 8:35pm
Commissioners Present. Elise Shearer(Chair),Thomas Murphy, Paul Miller, Laura Fisher
Commissioners Absent: Philip Thornburg (Vice Chair) Deanne Bush,Sherrie Devaney,
Linli Pao, Carine Arendes, Hemendra Mathur (Alternate)
Others Present: Councilor Marland Henderson, Council Liaison to the CCAC;Planning
Commissioner Richard Shavey and local realtor Neal Brown,Debi Mollahan and Diana
Weston from the Tigard Chamber of Commerce.
Staff Present: Downtown Redevelopment Project Manager Sean Farrelly, Community
Development Director Kenny Asher and Community Planning Senior Administrative
Specialist Chris Wiley.
AGENDA ITEM #1: Welcome and Roll Call
Elise opened the meeting and Chris recorded the roll call.
AGENDA ITEM #2: Review/Approve M Minutes
The four members present approved the August 14, 2013 CCAC Minutes. Chris will take an
electronic vote from the other members who were present at the August meeting to achieve
a majority approval.
AGENDA ITEM #3: Non-Agenda Items / Public Comment
A. Sean - there is an addition to the upcoming meetings list that's published at the
bottom of the CCAC meeting agenda. There will be a City Council Town Hall at
6:30 p.m.,Tuesday, October 29 that will include some discussion on downtown
development. Councilor Henderson said the mayor is looking for feedback from the
community. Sean will send out more meeting information to the commission
members as it becomes available.
B. Sean- this year CCAC will be recruiting for three voting-member openings and two
alternate positions. Elise is completing her second term the end of this year. Linli is
entering her third year of law school so she might not re-apply. Phil Thornburg's
term ends this year as well. If you know:anyone who may be interested in serving,
the applications axe online. There will be more information about the openings in
the October Cityscape newsletter.
CCAC Meeting Minutes for Wednesday,September 11,2013 Page 1 of 3
AGENDA ITEM #4: Explore Downtown Tigard Street Fair Report
Report on street fair and other downtown events— Debi Mollaban, Tigard Chamber of Commerce
(Attachment 1 to these minutes)
Debi Mollahan and Diana Weston gave an after-action report on the street fair. Overall it
was very successful and well received. They are looking forward to greater participation next
year as the public becomes more aware of this as an annual recurring event,and more
activities and vendors are added.
AGENDA ITEM #5: City Charter Ballot Measure
Review issues related to November 511,czty Ballot Measure 34-207—Elise Sbearer and Kenny Asher
Kenny thanked the committee members for their support for the measure and for
their input which helped the city craft a better explanatory statement. Kenny
encouraged members to channel their energies through the different organizations
they participate in throughout the city, to get the word out to voters about why the
passage of this measure is necessary to move urban renewal development forward.
Laura Fisher will get information to the CCAC members about the best timing to get
letters of support for the ballot measure to local publications. The election is
November 5. Ballots start going out 18 days prior, on Friday, October 18. Tom
Murphy said the message committee members should convey is that this vote is to
"let urban renewal work;"let it work as it was intended to be.
AGENDA ITEM #6: Tigard Brownfields Partnership Workshops (Attachment 2)
Discuss workshop plans and how CCAC wants to participate in October 911,meeting— Elise and Sean
CCAC will be sponsoring the workshop on Brownfields on October 9 in lieu of the
regularly scheduled CCAC monthly meeting. The State of Oregon has approved a
$25,000 grant which Tigard is using to build an inventory of downtown properties
that may qualify as Brownfields grant recipients. Specific guidelines will be released
in October with a submission date probably in December. The city will submit grant
applications. The first Brownfields public workshop is at the library on Wednesday,
October 9 at 6:30 p.m. It will be panel style. We want to encourage property and
business owners from downtown to attend. The first workshop will have a broader
audience. The second workshop will get into more specifics as to the process and
will be of interest to property owners who are considering participating in the grant
program. The grant will fund up to three Phase 1 environmental site assessments.
AGENDA ITEM #7: FY 15-19 Capital Improvement Plan Suggestions
Discuss and recommend potential new Downtown projects. All Downtown CIP projects will be
compiled and brought to CCACfor ranking in November—Sean (Attachment 3)
Sean will come to the CCAC in November with the list of potential Downtown projects.
The CCAC members will rank them. The CIP committee will look at all the
recommendations that come in from citizens at large, city boards or committees, staff and
the council along with available funding. They'll use that information to rank projects in the
CIP. Then it will go to Council for review. Sean gave the committee members the ratings
from last year. He highlighted the downtown related projects and projects that are unfunded.
CCAC Meeting Minutes for Wednesday,September 11,2013 Page 2 of 3
If members have any other suggestions to add to the CIP listing now is the right time to
submit those. CCAC needs to have their rankings in by the end of November. CCAC can
work on it at their November meeting.
AGENDA ITEM #8: 3'a Quarter CCAC Goals Update —Sean Attachment 4
Tigard Street Trail is a go. The remeander is almost certainly going to be in the CIP.
CWS wants to get the project done. The city is obligated to spend money on the Fanno
Creek Trail so this is the time to do the project. Since it was just approved, the
committee added the Commercial Street sidewalk to the 41h quarter update. The city did
get the CET grant from Metro for the Public Works feasibility study.
AGENDA ITEM #9: Liaison Reports
Facade Improvement— Carquest is the most recent applicant.
Art Subcommittee—artist Brian Borello is working on some ideas. He will bring
them to the art subcommittee within two to four weeks.
PRAB — Elise. Fanno Creek House is now complete. The city council will be there
tomorrow to do their goal setting. Steve Martin said they're already talking about how
they are going to set up rental and community uses.
There's $400,000 left for land acquisition for parks not including money set aside for
downtown park area.
TTAC—Elise. T LASC is beginning work on their recommendations for capital
improvement projects and prepping for their upcoming joint meeting with Council.
They discussed recent traffic delays and remedies the city initiated relative to the
development going on near the intersections at Dartmouth and 72�d and Hunziker
and 72nd The 99/Gaarde/McDonald intersection will be delayed from 2014 to 2015.
Cost for right-of-way in that area increases more than anticipated so other
approaches have to be looked at. The Walnut and 135th Street intersection signal has
been postponed for one year. That is being financed with MSTIP funds from
Washington County. New sidewalk next to Tigard High School going into Cook
Park is under construction right now. Fanno Creek Trail, Main St to Grant Street,
should be finished by the end of September.
AGENDA ITEM #10: Adjourn. The meeting adjourned at 8:35 p.m.
C.L. D iley, CCAC Re rdmg Secretary
ATTEST: r'��—' ���� C
Elise Shearer, Chair
CCAC Meeting Minutes for Wednesday,September 11,2013 Page 3 of 3
Explore Downtown Tigard f
� 4
i
e
{
1 - _
•
1
Summary
• Great success based on vendor
participation, number of activities,
attendance and verbal feedback from
vendors, sponsors and downtown
merchants who participated !
ExploreDOWST •
J:
Activities
Stars Wars Oregon Cloud City Garrison opening Ceremony
• Max's Fanno Creek Brew Pub Nano Beer Fest
• Demonstrations by
Mask & Mirror
U.S.West CoastTaekwondo
Westside Gymnastics & Dance Academy
• Virtual Dog Contest — Coordinated by Tigard Dog Park Committee,
supported by Downtown Tigard Events
• Music by
° Joel Stevens Trio
° The"Shwing Daddies"
• Kid Activities
Chalk Drawing Contest Sponsored by COT
Bouncy House
DunkTank
Facepainting through a Street FairVendor
• Beer Garden and remote Hispanic radio broadcast sponsored by La
Fue
Explore
• • •
y
Pics
pill
fff
w 4
IE� rI o'
LV
F � t
Explore il ��-" `• . x ��'„ � ', � t -� ,-: . -
i ""
�'?"� Ate-� i' ♦ �sr,.
W
Ilk
Explore
DOWN'T'OWN
Tigard
Marketing & PR Coverage
• Collateral Materials
Save the Date Street Fair Flyers for merchant distribution—several iterations
Posters (200+)
Signs— 30 lawn signs (re-usable)— Used on Main & Burnham— 3-4 weeks prior to event and up to
Banners (2 3'x10') at both ends of Main & 99W (up 2 weeks prior)
Virtual Dog Contest flyers in dog parks
• Explore Downtown Tigard Facebook and Web Site— Began in May
•
C.0 T. Facebook: Reasons to Attend the Street Fair (30 day countdown)
• Chamber Web Site (page and event calendar item)
-
• Unearned Media
"Master" release to Tigard Times and Oregonian
Online and print calendar listings, blogs—Total of 9
Articles in Times (pre and post)—Total 2
Articles in Oregonian ( , ,/ . - % -,
Articles in Cityscape and Neighborhood Web Sites (5 Neighborhood websites)
• Sponsor pitch letters and personal follow ups by Elise and josh
• Posts to Arts and Crafts websites for vendor pitches
• TDA meetings
•
Merchant newsletters
"Lplore
D •
Sponsors , Supporters �Volunteers
Sponsors
J
L MOIL NTI•IN
a TheT �les All but one a
i Chamber Member
- TIGARp AREA
Thank you to our Supporters
Oregon Star Wars Cloud City Garrison, Tyler's Automotive,
Pacific Paint, Dan Dolan, Scott-Hookland LLP, Tigard Vision
Center, La Fuente
Thank you to our Volunteers
Elise Shearer, Deanie Bush, Josh Paul, Tigard Rotary (-6)
Number of Volunteers: 12
Number of Volunteer Hours Contributed: 37 hours
Six of the volunteers were from the Rotary Club of Tigard
XPIote
Two of the volunteers were from the CCAC
One volunteer was from the neighborhood.
DOWN One volunteer represented a downtown business
F
_ Key Metrics
PayingVendors 47 for $ 1 ,796 22 for $ 1 , 175
Gross Sponsor $'s $ 1500 (2) $ 1000 (4)
Estimated Attendees 1200- 1500 Report says 2,000
In kind sponsors 5 2
Supporters 7 g
Volunteers 12 5
Financial Performance —$730 $g
Explore
• • •
Financial Performance
P&LforStreetFair2013
Revenue items In Kind Cash
Comments
' Vendors
$ - $ 1,795.75
Sponsor $3,897.00 $ 1,500.00
Bull Mountain Family Dental,Anytime Fitness Tigard
Grant from COT - $ 700.00
Subtotal $ 3,995.75
COT Events Supportfor Printing $333 June-Aug
Total Revenue $3,897.00 $ 4,328.7$
Expense Items In Kind Actuals
Fiscal Agent Fees $ 399.00
Equipment(tent, Bouncy house, Dunk Tank, Porta Poi $ 805.50
Advertising/Marketing/Signs $ 555.00
Music(2groups) $ 80000
Printing(Flyers,posters,handouts, program) $ 464,40
Photography $ 118.75
Operations $ 453.61 Commission on Sponsor Sales, Paypal fees,
Total Expense $ 3,596.26
In Kind Sponsors
Advertising $ 1,000.00 Tigard Times,trade for Sponsorship
Banners $ 700.00 Manufactured&Donated by B&B printing
Stage $ 342.00 Sponsored by DeAngelo's Catering
5 tents,60 chairs, 5 tables $ 595.00 Provided by Tigard Chamber
Emcee,set up,tear down-1 FTE all day $260.00 Tigard Chamber Membership Development staff
City of Tigard $1,000.00 City of Tigard Permit fees waived,electrical usage,
Explore Total In Kind Expense $g,897.00 $ barricade provision, PA system
DOWN 'NVN Net Income $ 732.49
rigard Event planning,coordination&
marketing,web,social media work paid under City Contract
till
>'.
GreatThings
• Star Wars Cloud City Garrison — Big Hit
They want to come back next year, line for pics
• Main Stage Location was great!
• Doubled number of vendors
• Great in kind sponsorships
• Virtual Dog Contest was a big hit!
• Good crowds for demo's on the stage and early music
• Anecdotal feedback from vendors and merchants was better
than 2012, happy
• Will be surveying for more specific, actionable feedback
• Parallel parking and sidewalks worked great for vendor
locations
• Rerouted Trimet *'
DOWNTOWN
Not So GreatThings
• Had to relocate a vendor
• Attendance fall off after 5 p.m. f.: `t,
• Street open, traffic and safety hazard ;
• Freight train ,
• Need more Kid Zone activities -
• Minimal DT Merchant Participation
Participants included: La Fuente, Rojas, LLLG,Tigardville Station,
Symposium,Tigard Winecrafters, Max's, Main Street Stamp
• Physical gaps in Main Street challenged keeping North End
activated
Primarily infrastructure limitations
• Undocumented Merchant guests (no $)
• Volunteer Engagement
• g Daddies did not draw crowds as expected
plore -7
1i
rjgard Even with a Great Event, there is always room for improvement
Y i
Next Steps
• Surveying various groups
• Vendors
• Sponsors
• Downtown Merchants
• Thank you letters going to:
• Vendors
• Sponsors
• Volunteers
• Apply lessons learned to next years event
• Create time line of actions for next years
event
Changes for NextYear
�- • Determine impact of Main Street Green Street project and plan
accordingly
• Address Main Street structural/physical gaps for better flow/activation
• Keep to 3rd Saturday —August 16th, 2014
• Change hours — end by 5 p.m.?
Will know more after survey results
• Leverage/partner with TDA for:
More Volunteer engagement
Improve Downtown Merchant participation, street activation
More sponsors — More $'s means more marketing, paid entertainment,equipment etc.
• Kidzone
More kid activities and carpet landing pad
• Garner some other major attractant such as art show or car venue
• Stage improvements
Relocate food vendors near stage
Band Shell for stage, barrier around porta potty
Carpet for demos
q ' ,
re
•
AS rkid A (fry 6
Tigard Brownfields Workshops and Outreach Plan
The Project:
The City is undertaking the Btownfields Partnership to address a key obstacle to furthering the Tigard
Downtown mixed-use urban village vision. The City has adopted the role of problem-solver in readying
private and public properties for redevelopment.A Business Oregon grant is being used to position the City
for future EPA and other funding opportunities to help remove brownfield issues on potential development
sites. Under the grant,inventory work is underway to help identify potential brownfield sites. In addition,two
community workshops will be held to engage the community in understanding, shaping and supporting the
Brownfields Partnership.
Purpose of Workshops:
• Build community understanding of and backing for Brownfields Partnership
• Position City as collaborative partner for property owners and developers—enhance City role as
problem solver in enhancing Urban Renewal Area redevelopment vision
• Educate community on Brownfields Project benefits and process—explain potential for public
health and alleviate fears about site assessment process (legal&liability issues)
Workshop Format:
The two workshops will be open to the entire community and designed to carry out the purpose described
above but each will have a different focus in both content and key target audience. Panel presentations
followed by audience questions and input will be the meeting structure for both workshops.
Workshop 1 - Urban Renewal and the Brownfields Partnership, sponsored by the City Center
Advisory Commission
Oct. 9 at Tigard Library Community Room 6:30- 8:00 PM
Theme-Introduction of the project to the broad community.
This meeting will begin with welcome and panel presentations followed by moderated audience-panel
interaction. Spanish translation to be considered.
Meeting flow:
Opening,welcome, explanation of workshop purpose, and panel moderation by the Mayor,remarks by
CCAC Chair (5 minutes)
Prospective panelists and topics (5-7 minute presentations):
• Sean Farrelly—reminder of the urban renewal vision and its benefits, explanation of Brownfield
Project and City role, explains the two workshop plan, describes complementarity with other City
projects/programs,informs audience of the need for them to demonstrate their support and how to
do that
• Lon Yandell (Terracon Environmental Consultants) —inventory update,what a Phase 1 report is,
expected outcomes of current grant work
• Kari Christensen (Oregon Health Authority)—health/quality of life benefits stemming from
brownfields efforts
• Amy Saberiyan (Ava Roasteria)—gas station redevelopment success story what property owners get,
what the community gets
Moderated audience-panel interaction (25 minute segment).
Mayor closes the meeting(5 minutes) by thanking audience and panel. Reminds audience of the next
workshop date and time.
09/11/13 CCAC Meeting Minutes 1
Attachment 2 (3 s/s pages)
Workshop 2 -Redevelopment and the Brownfzelds Project
Oct. 23 at Tigard Chamber 6:00- 8:00PM
Theme—Building a partnership among property owners,developers, the City and the community
This two-hour meeting will begin with welcome and panel presentations followed by moderated audience-
panel interaction. Spanish translation to be considered.
Meeting flow:
Opening,welcome, explanation of workshop purpose,and panel moderation by the Mayor/City Councilor (5
minutes).
Prospective panelists and topics (7 minute presentations):
• Sean Fanelly—reminder of the downtown vision and community benefits,explanation of
Brownfield Partnership and City interest in making key properties development ready,describes how
property owners/developers can show support for the Project
• Lon Yandell—detailed inventory findings, target areas for doing Phase 1, how property owners and
the City benefit from a brownfields partnership
• Karen Homolac (Business Oregon)—funding possibilities
• Developer(different person than at first workshop)—redevelopment success story,what property
owners get,what the community gets
• Mike Stevenson —pitch why it is essential for the business community to rally around the project
Moderated audience-panel interaction (25 minute segment).
Mayor/Councilor closes the meeting(5 minutes) by thanking audience and panel. Reminds audience of the
next workshop date and time. Makes the call-to-action by asking folks to consider property for phase 1
assessment.
Participant Identification:
• Downtown residents-Senior Center,
Hispanic community
• Property owners
• Business owners/tenants
• Developers
• St.Anthony's Church& school
• Environmental—SOLV,Tualatin
Riverkeepers
• Bike/Ped
• CCAC
• Mayor/Council/Planning
Commission/PRAB
• Other City departments
• Library users
• DEQ/EPA
2
Notice and Recruitment:
• Cityscape notice*
• Mailed notice to district property and business owners and residents and surrounding area*
• City website*
• City Downtown listsery
• Neighborhood Networks websites
• Work with Tigard Downtown Alliance and Chamber
• Informational display at Library*
• Posters for downtown businesses,apartment complexes*, senior center, church,school
• Personal invitations to key properties, businesses&potential developers
*abnsider Spanish translation
Key Messages:
• Attaining the Downtown mixed-use urban village vision will deliver quality of life (economic,health,
lifestyle) benefits across the spectrum of Tigard's community members.
• A variety of asset developments are already in place demonstrating progress toward the urban
renewal vision.
• Burnham Street improvements
• Fanno Creek Trail expansion
• Main Street Green Street plans
• New senior housing(the Knoll)
• Fa4ade/Targeted improvement program
• WES line
• Understanding and addressing brownfield conditions is an important next step in attracting
redevelopment that aligns with the vision.
Informational materials to support recruitment and education efforts:
• Poster advertising both workshops for posting in downtown windows, apartment buildings,library,
city buildings,church, school
• Media releases
• Fact sheet handouts
3
Agenda Item 7
http://www.tigard-or.gov/city_hall/departments/finance/cip_rrogram.asp
What is the Capital Improvement Plan?
The Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) is Tigard's 5-year plan for matching the cost of large-scale
improvements—like fixing roads, water and sewer systems—to anticipated revenues,like taxes
and bonds.
What Makes a Project CIP-eligible?
The city defines a CII' project as:
1. Any public facility project that improves or adds value to Tigard's infrastructure
2. Costs $50,000 or more
3. Has a useful life or extends the useful life of a facility for five years or more
Wante& Your Input on Capital ImprovementPrujeeft
The city is gearing up to develop the FY 2015-19 Capital Improvement project list and is
it looking for project nominations. Is your suggestion already on the list?? Check here first!
From August 1 through September 30, 2013, we encourage residents to suggest a project
for possible inclusion in a future CIP. Email your ideas to CIP Sue estions,
The timeline for CIP comments and project suggestions is as follows:
• August I until September 30,2013—Project suggestion period.
•
November and December',201.3—All submitted projects (includes citizen suggestions
and projects that are already in the current CIP) are evaluated and prioritized by staff,
council, and citizens from the Transportation Advisory Committee and the Parks and
Recreation Advisory Board.
• Mid February, 2014—CIP is submitted to the City Manager as part of the proposed
budget.
• Rrtst council meeting in.lune,2011--City Council adoption of Capital Improvement
Plan.
Where We Are...
Every year,between August 1 and September 30, a public comment period is open for citizens to
nominate capital improvement projects. Thanks to your suggestions and those of pertinent city
committees,new and existing infrastructure improvements throughout the city will be reviewed.
In November and December, a CIP team consisting of directors and staff from Public Works,
Community Development and Finance will begin evaluating and prioritizing projects submitted
for the FY 2015-19 program. At the same time that staff are prioritizing the projects, Council and
citizen advisory committees will also be prioritizing projects. Projects come from three sources:
09/11/13 CCAC Meeting Minutes
Attachment 3 (8 s/s pages)
the existing CIP,master plans, and Tigard residents.
Thanks to the voter-approved Parks Bond Measure,the citizen-led Parks and Recreation
Advisory Board has recommended multiple parks system projects including Summer Creek,
Sunrise, and Jack Park for development.
Not all capital projects are funded due to limited budgets. Instead,the city allocates money to
projects that are considered high priority or have available grant funding. Typically, the further
out projects are scheduled beyond the current year,the less likely that immediate funding will be
available for construction.
The current CIP includes the following projects:
• 72nd Avenue/Dartmouth Street Intersection Improvement
• Main Street Green Street Retrofit
• Pacific Highway/Gaarde Street/McDonald Street Intersection Improvements
What Happens Next?
We are currently busy documenting the recently adopted CIP. The presentation document will be
available in mid-August. In August'and September 2013, citizens can provide their ideas for
projects to be considered for the next CIP.
We encourage your project suggestions. To be considered, the capital improvement project must
be a public facility project that improves or adds value to Tigard's infrastructure; costs $50,000
or more; and has a useful life or extends the useful life of a facility for five years or more.
0,.,,Nof Pro,'et rf f,tsI, Irsti�.d
Fiscal Year 2014—2018 I Capita Impro•✓ement Ilan
Project Rankings
91 CIP Ranking Worksheet
93-96 Final Ranking Scores
The following matrix shows all of the projects within the five-year period that were scored and prioritized
by citizen member boards along with city staff.Citizen member boards including the Tigard Transportation
Advisory Committee(TTAC), Parks and Recreation Advisory Board(PRAB),and the City Center Advisory
Commission(CCAC)provided substantial input In the selection of those projects that were to be funded.
TTAC and CCAC scored all street projects.PRAB members scored those projects within the parks system.
Staff representatives from the CIP Management Team include Community Development,Public Works and
Finance.Each citizen member,along with staff from the CIP Management Team,score each Project based
upon an agreed upon criterion.Total scores are then calculated for each project with all citizen members and
staff scores given equal weight.A final combined score is then calculated for each project and projects are
prioritized based on these scares.Available funding is assigned to those projects with the higher scores.
• Every year,the CIP project list is developed from the existing CIP,Master Plans,staff,and citizen member
committee nominations.Note:Only those projectsfrom MasterPlan thatfall within the five-year period
are included on the list.
• The list of projects is prioritized by the city's CIP Management Team along with citizen member boards.
All projects are prioritized using specific criterion pertinent to each system.These projects are ranked
based on criteria ranging from public health and safety to funding partnerships.Each criterion is rated
on a scale from 0 to 5(see page 91). Project scores between the CIP Management Team and the citizen
member committee are each given equal weight and combined to arrive at a final score for each project
(see pages 93-95).
• Projects are ranked based on their individual scores and funding is applied to those with the highest
scores.Those projects that are already under construction are not ranked as it is known that they are
already funded and will continue.
7.01v 2018 Cal�lbf I�nprw Om¢nr vlsn I SC
Rating Criteria High Medium tow
r
The project eliminates
Public Health a current and present Reduces a current and Mitigates a potential
and Safety Public health or Present public health public health or Has no impact on Degrades public health N/A
safety condition.
or safety condition. safely risk. public health or safety. pr safety.
The proiect Alleviates an ongoing Cleans up past Has negative impacts
Environmental g g degradation or Has negative impact on the environment
Impact substantially improves degradation is the an environment which
P prevents future that cannot he NIA
the city's environment environment. d
is mitigated mitigated.
The project is required
to meet a state or is needed to bring a Does not make an Moves the system
Federal or State s stem componentu No state or federal y y
federal p rnilt or 'y p 5tanda.ds apply to progress toward further cway from
Mandates other entcrceable to federal or state meeting.state or ( state or federal N/A
standards. this project.
requirement. federal standards, l requirements.
The protect mr-oves
Livability/Vitality city wide livability,! improves city Wide [mprove,livabilay/ Improves livability/
Enhancements
bivatility/w alitylor vitality for some vitalit 1 for Does not improve N/A
alll segments
for- most segments. segments. ( few segments. livabdlity/vitality.
Council Goals The project is listed Is needed to reach
8ndiaectl relates Dues not relOaa to Is contrary to a
specifically asa at least one y
or interest rGone gcal.. any council pals. council goal. N/A
council goal. council goal. g
Community The project has wide Has mixed support Has mixed support mtki ' People do not have a..
Interest commuri;V support.
the project with most an even split of support opinion Ido not care) Many people oppose N/A
,supper-,. and�oppesiUn�about the prulect. the project.
The project vml'payor Willi pay for its self Adds operational cost
r Ndbs to oPerancnal Adds to o
its self over less than iry less has five ears per=Ronal
Y bus the cast is pal Cost Effectiveness y contbut ise cost the least blip s d cost without N/A
five ears In reduced' "r reduced cost for sYlth increased
cos,to the city. to citizens. cycle cost a�ternaRve. revenue offset.
operannnal revenue.
I
Allemate a risk that Alleviate a Hsk of FS Jevrate a risk of
threatens fife or Alleviatearisk that Alleviateariskthat
syshem nconvelure .: ' 3 stem nienc toth
System Reliability result in severe results in moor loss � causing Y g N/A
wpulrable halt rm
inconvenience to inconvenience to the
rzreparableh rm ro erty loss. of property.
the public cty staff.
The project fully Does not implement
Fully implements
Implements implementsatMakes progress a recommendation in Is not consistent
P at least one
more Than one toward meeting a an adopted plan or with an adopted Master Plan recommendation in an recommendation in an 4 n N/A
adopted master plan. master plangoals. is not.anticipated in system plan.
adapted master plan. a master plan.
The project is fully
Readiness to funded,is under Design is done,permits Is funded and ready to
Proceed construction or bids and right of way has start but no work has Has partial funding. Is not funded. N/A
have been receivedbeen secured. been completed.
The project has.grant Is listed for a grant Is funded by a law
Fundis interest loan.that Has muh1 le fundis
B funds awarded and and ingduing th receive h g Is only funded from
Partnerships will lose them if it does funding during the are time sensitive, sources which are not N/A
— — or is eligible fora time sensitive, city resources.
not proceed, budget cycle. future grant.
m tu—n ziar I 9'l
Priority Project Name Comments
Current Pavement Management Program In progress
Current Walnut Street Improvements(116th Avenue to Tiedeman Avenue) In progress-awarded$4 million grant
along with Walnut Street/135th Avenue Intersection Improvement through Waco
Current Citywide Sidewalk and Pedestrian Improvements In progress
Current Pacific Highway/Gaarde Street/McDonald Street Improvement In progress-awarded$7,6 million
grant through STIP,ODOT and Waco
Currens 72nd Avenue/Dartmouth Street intersection Improvement In progress
Current 42nd Avenue Sides:•alk{Waverly Drive to Cook Pork) In progress
Current Main Street'r,Een Street:Retrain In progress-$3.4 million In MT)P and
MSTIP funding
Current Main Street/Gree,•.Street Imp rovemenk.T-Phase 2 In progress-$1.15 million in STIP
funding
Upper Bcones Ferry Road/Durham Road Adaptive Signal Coordination System Fully funded.-awarded$650,OOD
federal grant
2 121st Avenue(lh'olnutstreet to Gaarde Street)Complete Street,
Whistler Street to Tippitt Street Unfunded
3 Walnut Street Complete Street,Tiedeman Avenue to Pacific Highway Unfunded
4 Citizen Request:Sidewalks—Tiedeman Avenue(Tigord5treet to Greenburairoad) Partially funded
5 Citizen Request:Sidewalks—Hall Boulevard(Bonito Roadto Durham Road) Unfunded
5Commercial5trecC Sdewatk/Lincoln Avenue to Main Street) Fully funded-pending TriMet funding
at 80-20 match
T Scoftin,s Streetjhail Boulevard/Hunziker Road Realignment U'nfwrtlEed
S EBnu11e..vad,1:Mc0onald Street Intersection Improvement(Left-7um Lore) Partiallytunded-willseekgrant
__ funding
5, t Bridge Replacement Unfunded
10 Citizen Request:Tiedeman Avenue/Greenburg Road/North Dakota Street
Intersection.improvements Unfunded-road study required
11 Citizen Request:Sidewalks—Hall Boulevard i8onifa Roadto MCDonald5treet) Unfunded
12 72nd Avenue Improvements(Highwoy217 to ElmhurstStrect) Unfunded
13 Ash<treet crossing of the WES Rail Line U,nYunded,
14 Tiedeman Avenue/North Dakota Street/Tigard Street Realignment Unfunded
15 Citizen Request.Sidewalks—72nd Avenue (Highwgy217to Bonito Rood) Unfunded
16 Citizen Request:Bull Mountain Road/Benchview/139th Avenue Roundabout Unfunded
17 Ghzen Request:Greenfield Drive Complete Street Unfunded
Staff Parific H,hwai Gatewatr(or Hall Boulevard)
Unto-(ded
NR Park Street Sidewalk(PcciJic Highway to Wotkim Avenue) Unfunded
NR Improve Warner Street
Unfunded
NR Main Sfreet Erldoe Poinnnq%Reha'bilitahon
Unfunded
Staff Update Transportation System Plan for River Terrace Fully funded
Staff Tigard Transportation System Development Charge e r Fully funded
Staff River Terrace Capital Improvement Projects r Unkown
_L1<-.Wit 00�el l,rnh�c�re:nent 93
=N.-. Comments.
Current East Butte Heritage Park Development In progress
Current Fanno Creek House In progress
Current Dirksen Nature Park(formerly Summer Creek Pork) Inprogress-partiallyfunded
Current tree Canopy Replacement Program In progress
Current Jack Park In progress
Current panne Creek Tri((Mow Street to Gram Avenuej In.progress
Current Fanno Creek Trail(GrontAvenuc to Woodard Park.) In progress-$802,400 funding through
STIP
Current Park Land Acquisition In progress
Current .Park Land Development In progress
Current Downtown Land Acquisitor, In progress
Current Downfmvn Park lmpmvements In progress
Current Tigard Street Trail In progress
Current COT/TTSD Park Development Partnership In progress.
Current Damage Tree Replacement Program In progress
1 Pulse Dag Park Fully funded-recommended by PRAB
1-UR Plaza Pur[hair/Design(Consfructior, Ueicnded
7 Fanno CreekTrzii Bridge Replacement(CirrSre-meander) Onhmded--rcqu,res(Ledingfrom CWS
3 Forma Creek Trail(Library to Milton Court) Unfunded
4 Senn Park Fuliyfunded
5 Bonneville Power Trail(Westside Trail) Unfunded-project in planning stage
at Metro
10-1.1 otitic Highway GatewayFlagpole(at Holl Bourewrdl Unfunded
12--UR Downtown Clock Tower Unfunded
NR. Turf Fields at Community Parks Unfunded
Stall- Tigard Triangle Area(P3) Unfunded
Staff Parks System Development Fully funded
a Update
Staff East Bull Mountain Fullyfunded
Staff Update Parks Master Plan for River Terrace Fully funded
Staff River Terrace Capital Improvement Projects Unfunded
Current City Hall/Permit Center/Police Exterior Walls In progress
1 New Public l4ln`ks Yard/Decommission Ash Street Yard Unfunded
5-UR Saxony Property Oemolmon/cite.Planning/Construction Unfunded
Staff Library Soil Removal Unfunded
Staff L.brary Automated Materials Handling System Unfunded
c 1 20114 2018 Carpal Irnpiovement Plan
PriorityProject Name
Comments
Current Water Meter Replacement Program In progress
Current Water Mali Line Oversizing In progress
Current Aquifer Storage and Recover Well tl3 In progress
Current Lake Oswego-Figard Water partnership In progress
Current Water Line Replacement Program Ih progress
Current Fire Hydrant Replacement Program In progress
Current Main Street Waterline.Replacement In progress
Current Pipeline Connecting 550 Zone.to 539 Zone _ In progress
Current Annual fire Flew Improvement Program In progress
Current Johnson Street Waterline Replacement In progress
I New Water Source Systemr++ide Improvements Fully funded
2 Barrows Read/Scholls Ferry Road 16'Line Extension(River Rood) Fully funded
3 Tigard High School Water Well Abandonment_ Fullyfunded
Stall Pacffc Ifdghway/Gaarde Street Utility Casing Bort Crossing Fully funded
Staff Water Master Plan Update for River Terrace Fully funded
Staff Ricer Terrace Capital lmpro'teznent.Projects. Unfunded
� ° P
Current StoRm Drain Major Maintenance Program In progress
Curren; Copper Crect_Bank Stabilization
In F,
I Fannc Creek Souin Bankfrom DeAnn Court to Brown Property Unfunded
2 Storm Drain Upgrade-Canterbury/105th Avenue to Pacific Highway) Unfunded
3 Hi lcrsst Drive(Summer Oen to MsI Avenue) Unfunded
Stall Slope Stabilization(Derry Dell CreeA at 118th Avenue) Fully funded
Staff Greenfield Storm Drain Replacement Unfunded
Staff Ellam Street Grudge Storm Rehabildanon Unturned
Staff Storm,vater Master Plan Update for River Terrace Fullyfunded
Staff River Terrace Capital Improvement Projects Unfunded
r
Current Citywide.Sanitary Sewer Extension Program In progress
Current Sanitary Sewer Major Maintenance Program In progress
Current panne Creek Slope Stabibzation(Arthur Court) In progress
Current Mal Street Sewer/Panne Creek C:ossiag EInn,ia!ion in progress
Current 129th Avenue,(Shnre Drive Sewer Replacement In progress
Current Tast Tigard Sewer Replacement In progress
Current Benehvias,Creek Sewer Stabilization In progress
Current 5ewei Rehabilitation Program In progress
Current Derry Dell Creek and Sewer Interceptor Relocation r Fully funded
Current Dartmouth Street 5-ver Repair r r Fully funded
1 Red Roark Creek/Slope Stabilization r r r Fullyfunded
-...)3$ i-au 1 hsprotrQrmo{at PIFs 95
Priority Project Name Comments
. t .
Staff 72nd Avenue Sewer Replacement at Bonita Road 'tt ttt fully funded
Staff Tree Planting Summer Creek(116th Avenue to 113th Place) It Unfunded
Staff Community Tree Planting tttt fully funded
Staff Sanitary3ewer Master Plan Update for River Terrace ttt Fully funded
Staff River Terrace Capital Improvement Projects Unfunded
S5 201a 2028 Capful mprov2 me n t 'lan
Agenda Item 8
CCAC 2013 GoalsQuarter Update
[the
roject Infrastructure
versee,review and provide input including I.a.
following key projects: L Green Street current bid date is Sept. 26.in Street/ Green Street Phases 1 and 2 Construction after January 1�`. Newblic parking lot on Burnham Street near alternative concept being developed forain Street Main St Gateway public art.pen space/ Downtown park / Plaza site ii. Parking lot opened in July.
iv. Consider public restroom accommodations Negotiations continue on Downtown
near plaza or transit center open space acquisition utilizing parks
bond funding
b. Monitor ongoing projects: Td
i. 99W/Hall Gateway- flagpole park er to be included in CIPii. Lower Fanno Creek Park improvements anODOT Rail being developed tore-meander truction of Tigard Street Trail
iii. Tigard Street Trail ents/open space @Main Street
vocable lease
II. Economic Development
a. Support the efforts of downtown businesses II a.
and property owners to better market the i. Explore Downtown Tigard Street Fair held
area. ii. Staff/CCAC involved with Tigard
i. Receive reports from and monitor the work Downtown Alliance meetings
of the contracted facilitator in downtown.
ii. Engage neighborhoods, business owners,
property owners,potential tenants and
developers within the process.
b. Ensure that Main Street/Green Street phases b.
1 and 2 are constructed with as little ii. Monthly update meetings held at Max's
economic impact as possible on downtown Fanno Creel Brewpub back room
businesses.
i. Apply lessons learned from completed
Burnham Street process to Main Street
/Green Street Phases 1 / 2.
ii. Include businesses on and adjacent to Main
Street within this process.
c. Promote downtown Tigard through outreach c. Metro Awarded$100,000 CET grant to
to developers and solicitation of businesses. City to complete redevelopment feasibility
studies for Public Works Yard and one
additional Downtown site
d. Encourage land assembly and direct
development o" tions.
e. Review developer incentives matrix and
advocate as necessary for implementation
with CCDA.
09/11/13 CCAC Meeting Minutes
Attachment 4 (2 s/s pages)
Agenda Item S
f Continue to improve our knowledge of the
downtown businesses and customer base
using census information,cultural
demographics, trends,and other statistics.
III. Facade Improvement and Targeted Incentive Programs
:::]
a. Review program outcomes and define
program success
b. Continue to promote, expand,and adjust the b.
program. i. Fagade projects:
i. Consider expanding program onto streets in Two completed: Pacific Paint,Wei Li
addition to Main. Five in progress: Brewpub, Rojas,
ii. Pursue endorsements from participants. Cafe Allegro,Fish Field, Symposium
Five in design:Jeffrey Allen, Kepler's,
Tigard Cleaners,Tigard Chiropractic, Car
Quest
TIP:Jeffrey Allen awarded$75,000
matchin rant
IV. Land Use&Transportation Planning
a. Advocate to TTAC and CCDA on behalf of
top three priority Connectivity Plan elements:
Ash Avenue rail crossing, Scoffins /
Hunziker intersection realignment, and
Commercial/ Main intersectiontea ent.
b. Engage in regular communication with TTAC b. Regular CCAC member attendance at SW
to ensure SW Corridor planning, and other Corridor planning meetings
transportation plans meet the needs and
values of downtown and the greater
community.
c. Begin an action plan to cover the remaining c. Financial Model completed for UR
ears left in the URD District
V. Communication
a. Liaise with CCDA, PRAB,TTAC,Budget Y.a. Regular liaisons established
Committee, and other boards.
b. Engage in on-going communication with b.Joint CCAC/CCDA meeting held.
CCDA, Council,and Staff Regular CCAC attendance at CCDA
meetings
c. Engage in on-going communication with c, Downtown articles appeared in Cityscape
citizens of Tigard through Cityscape and other in July,August, and September. CCAC to
means. sponsor Oct. 9 Brownfields Partnership
workshop