The URL can be used to link to this page

TRE2020-00056 1.7 City of Tigard, Oregon • 13125 SW Hall Blvd. • Tigard, OR 97223 1111 TIGARD 11/24/2020 Beau Saucedo 1800 NE Cornelius Pass Rd Hillsboro, OR 97124 Re: Tree Removal Permit Record Number: TRE2020-00056 Dear Beau Saucedo: On 11/24/2020 you submitted an application for tree removal at 12154 SW GARDEN PL. Your application specified that: 3 Red Oak is/are proposed for removal. Based on the information supplied on your application, this is a simple tree removal permit request. City staff has reviewed your application and based on the relevant approval criteria in the Urban Forestry Manual, your application has been: Development Tree Replacement Required Approved with conditions: The applicant shall plant a replacement tree for each tree removed, or pay a fee in lieu of planting, in accordance with the Development Tree Replacement Standards in Section 7, part 2 of the Urban Forestry Manual. Existing trees may be considered as replacement trees if they meet all applicable species, size, condition and location requirements in Section 7, part 2 and were not already required to be planted or preserved by the Tigard Municipal Code. This decision is final and valid for a period of up to one year after issuance unless otherwise specified. Nothing prevents you from submitting another tree permit application if the conditions and circumstances surrounding this removal have changed. If you have any questions, please contact us at arborist@tigard-or.gov or 503-718-2421. Please be sure to reference record number - TRE2020-00056. Best regards, Community Planning Division City of Tigard RECEIVED NOV 1 6 2020 City of Tigard I COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Er Tree Removal Permit Application CITY OF TIGARD PLANNING/ENGINEERING TIGARD Solicitud de Permiso Para Remover Arboles PROPERTY ADDRESS I DIRECCION DE LA PROPIEDAD g /) REQUIRED SUBMITTAL Address (amnion): L Z V 3(4 C�lLI ) G�G,YC�P K) lam. ELEMENTS REQUISITOS PARA APLICAR APPLICANT I SOLICITANTE (� Owner's Signature/Written m Nae (Nontbm): e J-e r ` gee .c , cl 0.c.tiC e_do Authorization Address (Die aion): moo he COY h-e t c,.k S I s R r-1 t o'1, bet✓o irma del duerio/Autoriracidn por esctito Phone(Tel):503- .13 -7(7$7 Email: &cut,Soti..Lea> rnero-rCh e1ndSGc ,cesAn Site Plan (show location& Owner(Duero): El Same as applicant ,species of each tree,2 copies) (Igual al sokcitante) j Croquis(Indicar ubicaciony especie de CONTRACTOR/ARBORIST INFORMATION ' coda drbol,2 copias) INFORMACION DEL CONTRATISTA/ARBOLISTA Documentation(from removal Company(Cornpariia): RN:MA rC h 1 r`e£ Se r v' CR- criteria) Documentation(del criterio de Contact person(Cordate): PAPci-c,� CZt-A-Ce d c. ocion) LLC ISA/CCB#:Pn(o4'i 3 ii-/ I kt zz(5-9!Expiration(Enbit tailin1 12/3i Ito 2,) Application Fee (complex only) Pago (solo para el proceso compljo) Address (Dimaion): Veil) lie- Ctsrn2li,A S pass iecke,0 Phone(Tel): $—�.3'7COS7 Email: 6eccw .-.r•e.o e MCY1arc n t a.t ci S!•;.(.) .C4 is.1 TREE INFORMATION—to be completed by applicant INFORMACION DEL ARBOL — el solicitante debe completer esta parte FOR STAFF USE ONLY Tree species (Especie del drool): Ve 4 Oct V-5 Solo pars use del personal #of trees (#de arboles): .3 REVIEW PROCESS Tree location(Uhimadn del drbol): csj E 01440 d Simple ❑I lex Fee(complex only): Reason(s)for Tree Removal I Razones pars clottar el Athol -'C7 Case No.-i,I�-C2+�[-Cl I. SIMPLE REVIEW PROCESS ( PROCESO DE REVISION SIMPLE Related Case No(s): FSRSV Tree is a hazard as determined El Tree is dead(Arba!estd muerto) Application accepted: l by an Arborist(El arbol es un ( Q J///1 '/_c peligro segrin k determinado par un ❑ Removal required for approved land use or By: /`- _Date: //[ lX arbolista) building permit(Necesario pare la aprobacion de an permiso de use de suck o construction) Application determined comp! Tree is in an advanced state of �, decline(e rbol cod en ertado de oots are causing damage By: t�J Date: // yl� deterioro avangado) (Las raker akin causando dark) Translated: 0 Conflicts with TSP Project ❑ Thinning necessary to protect other trees (Conflicto con un proyecto de (Es neasario ralearpara proteger alms croaks) By Date: tranrpartacidnTSP) 0 Location does not meet planting standards MommonityD aWndUse Appinlioaa\02_Fo®a (Ubicacidn no curupk con normal de plantation) and T�l �\ Use Apptintiona Rev.09/2018 ❑ Species is on nuisance tree list (La esperie arty en la Arta de arboks ❑ Recommended by fire marshal pevb/emati%r) (Fla ncomendado por d marircal de incendios) ❑ It is infested with pests or disease ❑ Tree has sustained physical damage (Este infestado con plagas 0 (Arbo/esta ftsicamente dabado) enfermedades) For complex reviewpmcvss see rampage j Pam el?war()de to rra ion amp*tea la plitsimapasina City ofTigard • 13125 SW Hall Blvd. • Tigard,Oregon 97223 • wwwtigard-or.gov • 503-718-2421 • Page 3 of 4 TREE REMOVAL PERMIT APPLICATION IL COMPLEX REVIEW PROCESS (check applicable reason and provide brief proposal summary) PROCESO DE REVISION COMPLEJO(Marque el motive aplerabky di rasa expliradon breve) ❑ Blocking views or solar access 0 Undesirable species 0 Other(explain below) (Blaqueo de vista o aarro solar) (Etpetie no deseada) Oft (001401 db4e) Please leave blank for staff I Dejar en blanco para el personal THE APPLICANT SHALL CERTIFY THAT: EL SOLIC]TANTE CERTTFICA QUE • The above request does not violate any deed restrictions • La solititud anterior no viola ninguna restriction de las that may be attached to or imposed upon the subject escrituras de la propiedad que pueda see conectada a o impuesta property. sober la propiedad en cuestion. • If the application is granted,the applicant will exercise the • Si la solicited es concedida, el solicitante jercera los derechos rights granted in accordance with the terms and subject to concedidos de aaeerdo con los ter'minor)sujeto a las condicionesy all the conditions and limitations of the approvaL limitations ele la aprobacidn. • All of the above statements and the statements in the plot • Todas las dedaraciones anterioresy lar declarations en el plan,attachments,and exhibits transmitted herewith,are croquir,los documentos ach;untos,y muestras trasmitidas,son true;and the applicants so acknowledge that any permit venaderar,y los solicitantu acr ncanoan que cualquierpermiso issued,based on this application,and may be revoked if it is concedido, barado en erta solicited,puede rer revocado si re found that any such statements are false. encuentra que alguna de afar aftrmaciones es falra. • The applicant has read the entire contents of the • El roleitante ha lode tech el contenido de la aplicacidn, application,including the policies and criteria,and incluyendo las pokticary eriteriosy comprende for requisites para understands the requirements for approving or denying the aprobar o negar la solicited application. SIGNATURES of each owner of the subject property required. FIN • re c:da ueiio de . . e en cu. tion req eridas.w Jr Iii012.0 ,0 4 /UYLAL&I "'' , trent name(Nero ) Da ecba) 6k Ain, bC 26244 It/it Ow es signature (F. del duetio) Print name (Nombre) Date (Fecba) Owners signature (Firma del duel o) Print name (Nombre) Date (Fecba) Authorized agent's signature Print name (Nombre) Date (Fecba) (Firma de agente autoriada) City 0/Tigard • 13125 SW Hall Blvd. • Tigard,Oregon 97223 • wwwtigard-orgov • 503-718-2421 • Page 4 of 4 it. MONA•. RECEIVE.() RCH Jeremy(Beau)Saucedo ISA Certified Arborist PN-6893-A NOV 4 ZOZC 11/11/2020 Monarch Tree Service CITY OF TiGA PLANNING/ENGINEERING RING Monarch Tree Service Park 217 Hazardous Tree Removal Arborist Report 12154 SW Garden Place,Tigard Oregon We are requesting the removal of(3) Hazardous Red Oak Trees(see attached map). Tree#1 Red oak dbh 24"-3/10th, the live crown ratio(LCR)35%, height is 55',crown spread is 45' overall health is in severe decline. Pavement over the roots is 75%of the drip line,this tree was planted in a tree island in the parking lot,with minimal root space growth. This trees root system is causing infrastructure damage to asphalt and curbing. There was recently within (5)years a French drain that was installed within 5-8'of the root flair, root damage may have occurred to this tree,as we are seeing numerous amounts of deadwood and tops breaking out and dying within the canopy. Tip and top die back are a sign of root damage and or root rot,which doing my Level 2 assessment of this tree, I did not see any fruiting bodies at the base or in the root plate area. This area must be very saturated to have the French drain installed. Targets that are involved are moving vehicles under the dripline, parked vehicles and people. This area is in constant use. Tree#2 Red oak dbh 19"- 1/10th, the live crown ratio(LCR) 20-25%, height is 50',crown spread is 45' overall health of this tree is in severe decline. Pavement and sidewalk over the roots are 70-75%of the drip line,this'ree was planted in a tree island in the parking lot,with minimal root space to thrive, which has contributed to the damage to the root system. The largest lower later limb (scaffold limb) has a large longitudinal branch crack that over hangs the parking lot spaces as well as the road. The tree is very sparse and has multiple previous branch failures. Top and tip dieback are a sign of root damage and or root rot,which doing my Level 2 assessment of this tree, I did not see any fruiting bodies at the base or in the root plate area. This area is in constant use. Tree#3 Red Oak dbh 27"-7/10th,the live crown ratio(LCR)55%,height is 50',crown spread is 45' overall health of this tree is severe due to the root rot that is visible from my Level 2 assessment. Pavement and sidewalk over the roots are 30%of the drip line. This tree has root rot at the root collar of the tree (see pictures),this is a sign that decay is heavily present in this tree,removal is highly recommended here for the safety of the tenants,the building,vehicles,and pedestrians. This trees root system is causing infrastructure damage by lifting the sidewalk,creating a tripping hazard/liability. Targets involved due to the entire tree failure,vehicles, structures, pedestrians and tenants. This area is in constant use. 1800 NE Cornelius Pass Road, Hillsboro, OR 97124 Phone: (503)486-5154 MONARCH Jeremy(Beau) Saucedo ISA Certified Arborist PN-6893-A 11/11/2020 Monarch Tree Service Mitigation will be tree for tree on site, 1.5" caliper Red sunset maple. If you have any questions regarding my finding and recommendations, please call me or email me at the information below. Jeremy(Beau)Saucedo ISA Certified Arborist PN-6893-A Arbor Branch Manager Monarch Tree Service Beau.Saucedo@monarchlandscape.com Phone: (503) 593-7087 1800 NE Cornelius Pass Road, Hillsboro, OR 97124 Phone: (503)486-5154 Proposal 11-16-2020 Tree Quantity: 9 MONARCH November 16,2020 t [; _.-. Proposal#:193258 Tree Care Service Address/Location Monarch Tree Services Park 217 Oak Tree Removals and Mitigation Plan 9- Monarch Landscape Company 22-2020 Washington&Oregon 12154 SW Garden PI Tigard,OR 97223 Jeremy(Beau)Saucedo ISA Certified Arborist PN-6893-A beau.s a u ce d o(W m o na rc h l a n d s c a p e.co m te1:503-593-7087 Species Qty Service Mitigation Replacement Tree 3 Pick up,install,tree ties and tree stakes Northern Red Oak 3 Removal Northern Red Oak 2 Stump grinding where locates allow for replacement tree-shrub Stump 1 Stump grinding below grade where locates allow Proposal#193258 Page 1 .' "s II 4 MONARCH Park 217 Oak Tree Removals and Mitigation Plan 9-22-2020 c c... r ! ._ • ,.., teacntl(9) ��!<': Satellite C,5 ,' ` r� Northern Red Oek(5) >� L LJ 4. . l 1 `.�Jy #3 �` -,i, '+:K••.t.,�r..•\ ., "`1'. 1*�1C•• ,1 'w,: 'i } + ! " 4 . irv/ 7. A1r'i,•M 4 P!IltItt iJi.� . f it, ' 4 .i .- / % Qe 'S . r ' r ...x- t " • 4� ( (Cs. •J 4 J ; • < 2,,.4. \ S. "1 rr 1.4e�� T Cd " j 7�/. 441 11. �� . r '1,,wV. $•' 4'0. i f.. ,,: *, r ! ~.• !� C Cfi1 ` * �/�t r~ , � k � • � / � .' A • i( ��, Z.te)- :\ a ' ' : q ' b �' J \ 'e1f.. . t. 4 , xV !: 'y ' .i?- r,,'" -+'e l'` :gam" , ' ��' ,,, %,•. tit .., , \ �, e. ( (. JAY 46 1�r• �`�; pF r 9 } ♦ r.�(• �j�. y� 1 /. 1 \ ' #�`` � � fizr a, ti -TT d5r�yy,� .r „ai 1,:.. _!` '(r- '} 1 4 '• "-. ,fi. .— • ItLW 4a `✓ tort• { il✓g.+..r--`,j " . [ it+,� / tr et ) n • ., • ?' r�If %�.x•G^,yy •.irk S'�g,, k '.z • fir'' IL'. ' •Y „� 4 a r ,•,t�X• x j. • y 3 •t ia►t -' a t ; ? :rr�C Ay ;',. ". r,('' e... " tier • •p .. •. S ° e r. ... • • *1w. . < err t yet � � •r ,' - •'a��r(y•� f t 'x' r " + .a Ian 4P, 5 .; 7 J t 1 ��".•, '. 1 r. 1 r i a �t ;' .t, ' �1'S`;.. n i �L , C:' +` `� . 3 ' s e s y o- � ';¢.4(1• fI7 • ,F t , .� • • M@D ona 0202U lrno1ry¢VUMU.Pi 3K3 lgM1•nbt11.5 PSe(rt) PnrtNno Oreoon ST33P or(rrFr(1n (L S.(Lenionral Survey T rrs oh IN. Proposal#193258 Page 2 psi ,f; •'' • f f*,1 ;!k.4i4,0?;..'•tti; r 4., . , i•Avi.*. Ate — . - - , . „ . i „,-„ -1' •-4 t IT• 3 r 1 Ka r • :.e" r ' ' 44-r:zH N__4a6 4 'Ili • • t.•1 • • �- —• .+ n fhr,t. •` f-1 . �• .• I f rnft )X • •. } 1 A ��. .. 1'i I <', ' ! ppi �, / y� f7�� s yfr�la.q Lt' � rl.t f , { .'M � LJ J f � i r• :sIV ;1_'•_ �•1�,'S�1pt• �Z s i. g`�y,�.+; i . -�•y a�$s.-. v � J f i f �vpx i�,Q-r•t't+��K yse l iw� ! ! — ! V . �f LC t� ' 4. 7' lV� � ••� f 1• ` J ! , f • � ' d ya 71i 1...lff '� ! _ ii _ �/ 1 Al. jf�t pp_ , ar.{ t yy . •, , ) "oit,:.- —.,-- '0.• r 0 :,__T A. - a . f:.. 4 x st y' e , ,, ,! ,, ,.„. I; ('0,'::•!*4,410'P.,/ ,1 . '1 • f if'''' 10,-..- .91 -p, S �, I. • r•��l'rt,y -k�aj i' 'IS.."';‘ F iv41,,t j f ! 1 ii w.iffe J'` �[i.�'iI , . y . y d•rl,3 s W sr , ��/1i..i. ✓'�f ,� .•wit,_ '1. a ,,. fr ,' a.' y- 7 f �}r 'J.:,_`''. 1 �`i." may, L'.+( . f �:', c f • j. r.______ 4'-'�^'"1, .• ..sit :Z' ii L. 1„1 L�-f •.ice ir 7 y • , 1 . 1 Ar2 ��, i ' t� it IL�I ttt�4' , s is ,J �4- & fkin n , I Nil 1 � [ ,� ,R. fin, .. "\t °} tor, lei` x• `rY , obi i' ki .• • ,,, : „ ,•a 7 t r' iti'fy. t �•i�.a_Ayr' 4 ��J,�,r6..,L �• t!:Ht�h.c t� t,.t �}�,i f - ..; .r - C.•: 1 ,t k ., ! I y k,rC.*,•,-1. µ.•. • J 4 ,.ta,i{t ,.` - -• C✓• „ilf •S,?�L "1,,.. ' Y: ++fl Jy L-A•n• ! ; ! ` r Alt . ": 1 L`i, rt ••7"t'• . r r .,, '. +C :,'�' t Mom' ' , i4"• k`r•v� �y) i� t��' ari It} ; t' ^.$ i t .k . ,,ar�r. ;" 1 $em u it `� •`' 1- '�µ�si ,,?.,. f}' - 'n' ,, A'� ' t •l Mk r'Yri i=i,fiS yad� i,. jbs 1 . • ,- /yt...,:,' Y• -, C lrl,`.. t ti w { H 1 nY w,4d•� y . t. R ti-' �.,i '� !S: \ i:r.i5 4 i�tr ( tV + r Grp X4.� i�,i'h� _ Y J 1 i y#g i r/.k� ^' '1;4Yj 4 `ter,= �f i�'(•?• �1''• -.y k.ice••F,n`\! ,- , 1-,,,.,Lj Y' �.� %�. , )b't' r`. t. V . I < . ! t ,v .ice , iwr ' ik a! ^y � J. h .ST r i+ ~5 . tit!�• �, l . .441•.\i\"�. 1.� ^•1.• �} i.lti 4Ni _ T�>�.,5+�[Y r rr `y't� Y 3p.+'Yr ..I. r ,ml 'Pi:...''. I � .a -ry "[a��>� '• 'tp T y'r t ;%'� 1i .- A; �s, , it ♦. ty ,, ` 11,.:' '�Lt}`a L Li . 1, t✓,� : WX ,M?. .'TM '1 w t 17 / e,4:, it 'i1e ,.:',, , ''^tl`r�,S'.— R"•,� 0'K i.YUt ,J\ 'lld v]�lyye. ^Y�tx`.1hti,�A. .:.+�.: .ate. . 3 3. M1 " � WH;i LS D ks r.i. ' fr rI.,-,..----_ F { y + ram : ) 1 , 71) k_ Tcf MJ r` =1 A L 4�9 1e14 + •_� 1 1 ?g •j j � i• �, Y ' F , f V . �. ,,0 I 1 t '� ` f!' t a �` YY t� t � c •1 T Y . ' < <y Y ttt .�'}`,�� '�?{ i �� > i�yf t f �.1 '�� I.s�� I tier �i +. r 4 ' j.a 1 55 { i)a t. , 1 ,k?,y +y t i .4 ' 1 , 4 I ' 1 Iiif� 51T !� 4 .i• l+r slf a�7 ' _PI!� + C +"I i [ tiip ttr T1 M � I �„y a 1 '1'...)„,.. . ,....,i, M' t.tl^•f � '6ikl:� / � {f�YCt.. lt,,, ,, .1 f'. 1,,,,,,*,,,k„. . , F �iO4 ! Yy f Y^ 1 '-'4' ', AF{y, Kt ti t k I.Jtw (,, t^ " ; I �eeqq 4 ��,� �1'• ) � y , lit • ttiiiiirii4--: y 1, '4.4 k, I 'Ai Y 11'f J�/ f yj} 1 ((, ) . i y T4, .t.)H • 1 1 - f f 1 Y{(+1 rQi Y �+,1• ti•l t t�lif',�' 11 ): F f rl `tP m s $ i t 1 tr 1"3 ofr : x x �cy(', C i` q .'i 1 t � li .1 ttt + '"4i 1 f't 1 it ) i,l { t - � ) I • , k f S' ` bt11:r-+1 'p 1 1t 4 it f 15 4 ,,•• , 1 � d l + � •'nil � � t +,y�t,y� • -�� 4)tt� ��:t� �6Y 4 1+ 1 p + f t * i4' , 61 .,4�� a r y o, Y ' 4 a k :' 1,4 .i ;+t+ 1 S f ) 1;I 4i) y °tr j i p�� "�t� +ft�i'V.}} � Zsf ' { i` tfti '�i•L': • t < J• p., }� ; �� 1 j(�.'it , � 4t I cr � ')±t �jr f+. �‘.:1 a� kt 1,�� 'i�t ) t+�. :::Iir' .;4;6 ',)J' 4 Y 1:: ti l rl" ,t r� + �, . t 14 c:\t, 1 'III' �: ' ,.k';„: , ,:...;4:1': ,a-{+', > 8443, • a. a t t '7.4?, .. • •1 i` C ?S.,-, . r t y ..i II,l { ` }' iv) s i iiii t9# r7 �s' ' .S 1 rt• , .,.. ,. 1,,,..,:,-.),ort-,....k-- '''i. 9'1, -,E , VI S4) • \ }k Sri f 46A "f ' ) ,' t 4 1 P't' '.4* ,I a.:,\ ak1° f s' n ^V a N° , , `�' P y 1 y t '? Y' t{ir i 1 ., a \\\ •q Y '.I {.- ty F f if xxxaaa e t ° cite It k �'' t� ,,.`-• a P ,y ) a tv t r ', }Y� P % r '' k 8,'.. ''8 fi I p w ' A , 1 ,f , =,, -. n.r. i•t..ySf �, 3' .1. + C.' N a , , i '99- • ,,,,, •,. - • ' f%'r • !.,•.,,,.. . . V- 4 I '''‘i flif .7.•''''l• $ e - , • lie ' ;74-7-• ... ' ' ' 7 # ,.....ir:{04:114 , . 40- :1 :1,.,,$,.., 0.1...- - i . , • ..., , . , ,. ,p • ,.r I. Tree#3 ' i • 4 d ' • ' ' ..r.,' trifijoill i r t414 ° 2tiiii 4 r . A- •... 1 . • 1.1110,1„, .. 1, , . 0., f .. r,:..-.• 4 ' • . „• 2... • All ' i • i., .. . . 1 717 o -1 Tr „r 'tf - A1/4.4'... •,011". 4 r 1 I 't . ,7 i.$.,-it, ,.fr • I.. f 'pp,.. -: ' .,,,, ,... ,•7 r . .,4 , •Pi C., 1 ir .4' gd. . . , . 4,• • 4°' , Ir.' ° ti I ir ' ;j7'-C;. .‘14:0.• ' '• . '.. • 'i ' 4 . . .4 1 ,,,I,. .f - 111,t ' /A 1 , 1 I a. , ni• 4 .- 041 44A. 4 V. , k • z . tP;S:•:nPlif. «ivilfavojic ,,, :•,471.,f '4! - :Zeit- :c., i I• .y, . ' ' •' 10 i• ••• f' ''e /it v'iliv • .4 ' '.. .sir A • :, • .,. .47i , .. ,•-- ..., . , ,v,-„Jx. lo..--.5...... , . ,.. .4„, • ikr.,,,,,F , ../4. 4!...' '4;... .4-,10" - 0.5"': ' 41 '4(' .t% ,.:Y.„-4 ':, - 7,....;-,A_•• ',.., ' itloydrdi Jr* '0',1 1.4 • 4." I f " , Zr 0+ $ 74. il _ .- -tv 4 .A. - • .. - . 1 :-, 7%,.."7.'''fr .. •_, A. P'-'; . . • iw. .:: • `.',, lie.' • .41,- •,,, ". ,r • 4, •44;%, • 4 I,c:,r ,jr.,Thle ''' •1111....." . , " '.• • ' ir't •• Jlt•J . .44,.. ' 4,.•,',f • t'':,44.' ' 4,,, .4 .4-----• . 7 '.. r-fg i 410„,,%-;4111:P '. 11 7, d la 1 011„„,,, ,•."1.• •,.,-./ T ... ,.... . :17i'f%414' •" •if'- -."rW - "., ir , "1°4-fir••.- .r '• •.7'..A,° - .•'14. i;4,-......:11 t.1.7:./.:"..! *PA, ,0.,....0••: , ,. . ... ..„.-... I.; ..- ....,;,..-,',,,& /*,,,-,_,....44,:, 40.0,.. ....24. „,.. 1,'.•,...... . ..,- , - ,r i g.7, • ,„ i . - '-.Ele.OP aliln .....- " 12 .'•. 424-- l'1;t• ' ' Yarfriltar‘.i., .0.1 sr(457A, 44'..-t.::'Ace. -,..__*=• Wtr.),1 - -, :- : '`--.7:V. 4,rrAl :,- , 1... • -. , ,,,f4A ,L, • . .40,e./-- vi• -e, .. , F; 4...,,,owareals.,..1 .rs'iiii ' 4 9..".' :!) ii . . -4•0°• . bifir••••• ..04-0J . ... k•i -4, .AL , e. .r. . ..7.•,e-c„-. • -,-1-- .?-• - ....- - - •-• ., f_ '.''•-.' . . " ' _ . ty,-f ,., ..;-it.r • . , . !"--::'' .-4... • 0. 11 .. - --: el.; • / r ....z.:•!.:- • ) - ' • • •• • 2 8 _ 1 , 0 i•1 ! • ..,• l'. ,.. ;- • i . I . -:---- I . i - ' .' 14 •'-'-'. ',"• 7. - - • ,,,.. 7 ..,..„.".00- 4:1,..i., ,.-,i • .:.i.,:z, ;.:„,,.*'..ide;' ,#)141.e.;/. IT , t.,..-...f.&.„ 7.,, '' •• it:::--.4"..i.'. ' .'A.F..4%,''' • O., , ' - , 7-74b,j,,.17.7,-. A. -5r4.11,0...44,;„! p ,lorl ',V'Ef it:- 7 'I •-•..i, ,,,,.oy. ..• ...".. •r..1111p49-_.3,..,Ir -.4 I., -. °O.' "14; '9 -• "-.--r.:1-414.4 - ....7'if13 ..: •!''•.--."if•tql 4F-41"• ir :di /O. , - ' 11-".5414:'-. A-•''.4 ..ifroZ.101.-‘1.:i'•, l i -' ....14,••• li - , • . o, 11-.• f..,...":ite!,, .:.7.:.• • „...44.•,- 4.i. A-_,1". I,-. ", ;I. a;L. • ' . - 7 ..., ''''ftif"-,t.,- "4-':;(lie..'... .. - .' -.A: •- 4.. ....., . II. . . - 0 , 5,f*9,140,nal 4 -"Pip '01 •- " ' --1! -,t' 16 'Jr-'4 - .. •-ir,-.$4 -- ' ' " •--- e„;-•••• , -. --. •.:-,p.• - 41-414;4114'' " -- '-',v- ',..' ,4*-1'.:*S,..,' , / ,Itp-, . , ..- :.,4,-..."-. ....-..1.1P • ,..- - r. .,.., . ...,„...,,,,,,,,..._ . , ..., • .. . . 411. s % 44, : fir" •" Iti,• I I.; 1 ..0 p T.., r ft:Wier,. ., I .6 , L.! Ir .r lb •RI/AN 1 P. '.' ' '''.#Ir 0.,........0, ..•:-7 „1.- 7 -, . &,• 13: • . t Nil .. Aft .- • ige-;:, 4,' -.A., ,..„,..• --44, ..,44., ..• : 2916,4 „„ , ,,i,. 0. . ,s), .,..i.r.,i elk; .........riLm--,ir J..•.:. •111. , 'lie .74eto,••0•<44,:144.!ii ./›. •j!IP • •4 1k .4, „.4.84 :11 4 4. .„ . Vilijr••::V,'. : t:•(•'•„1.e. 'V• ' 4..41f• •ZO.13" .1 .,..},. .....t1L4•Lgit:r4•.''''Cl.. 'Ilir . 4. ' I t .r' - )11., :Avi*.4.:zr 1 r'' • :1 .."1)1' . . , •ill,, .•••• %,..,•• '- ...n,411 :•%,,•4"...44, " Apro 7 0 .4 d ..._,. v....4%r . .f4 :...,01,1_ i'4't,44, . "INO41.41 ' "..t, 4,, •( A lit ih, •', 011°. 4 ..• • •••- ,•• 4.- ' • t.10••• •: Iii(I • 44'Ap ,." . W.4 '''' 4.-'• • -A. 1 ' A \ ' AL. ;•• 'i • ttf ...Ir. . '71°7 ' Tief A •4.0:14..- A.4.71.- •,"'*%" r , - 14-. . i 4,..- . -.4. • r •.4t.v 1 , . 4..4. '.4 •• A. "itt ill7k. ' '''' a* #.."2.4K.. •. . ".." .4. g :11 •,i • : fil .. 44..•41 . 4 01.1401. ,41 •4. :.: : , 44 ••• ,p,: '141111k • 4r- ....:- , •‘‘,'a - 4- 1,.. .; ... '1 ;• . 4 6'4i;V:4444 .' • • f ' *•••‘*.'" r: I •it'4,1? x *, - • .,, ' "..,i. •., it r . ) ...4, . , - * * 'ni •rat 1 0• I I- iir f ''', - '0.,ifa ' I/ . 0, ,I.•71P; • • • :4 A, 04.1 • . 4 64%1. yoi iel.wlf ..n.•• hit tat.- .. .. s, 9 .A.:0111`. .,,, , . 10.•,,,..., ;-iife , .eso,,,,, , •,,rt, st:..=41, r,„dr. .... 0 - . ' ! • Ile i . ,•f t-*:• eAlra i• - .*" •,:r .-4, .., . .- 1, lit. -q.,• • ‘ „ I lit 4f9,.....a a o'• , • 4 4,.' • .,* • • fl. • 9 , .. ..4...2 ••••••••-pr .. .0 •.ii. , t i. ..,, .1 it. jimi -.• ,'•••,;(11 41::. ,. ,• .. .„.. 4 . g 4' , .s ....f i... .,..._:$,.... .. j..f. „ii* "". . - A• '_ 't '4* -- . -, Risk Categorization Likelihood Failure Impact Failure&Impact Consequences Target Condltion(s) (from Matrix rl (Target number Tree part a of concern a d A ? u c Risk or description) A m 3 > a m 2 a m c $ Y } m G c : rating a a E i' 3 u _m E a t m c m > (from co. a. aV £ > J 2 2 m N > > z N , matrix 2) F)44‘441 at„.,\21 V t F Vol 1Peopkt, (Li- o_ &ASC ?() W ?r 1A1'11 fo5 ;o '° Matrix 1.Likelihood matrix. 1 ! .._._!_._ _ ) _ _i__. Likelihood Likelihood of Impact of Failure Very low Low Medium High Imminent Unlikely Somewhat likely Likely Very likely Probable Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat likely Likely Possible Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat likely Improbable Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely - • --- Matrix2.Risk rating matrix Likelihood of Consequences of Failure Failure&impact Negligible Minor Significant Severe Very likely Low Moderate High Extreme - Likely Low Moderate High High Somewhat likely Low Low Moderate Moderate North Unlikely Low Low Low Low . o Notes,_ explanations,descriptions CAA- 4 17CSl%� 2-0*- i S a t^tci�Ll+ OJF \1-F.A b ,it, (Ty 2;5 I APip +a—& M ga n options n 1. V-U010^("C'1 V Residual risk 2. Residual risk 3. Residual risk 4. Residual risk Overall tree risk rating Low 0 Moderate 0 High7 Extreme 0 Overall residual risk None 0 Low 0 Moderate❑ High 0 Extreme 0 Recommended inspection interval Data Ittpnal 0 Preliminary Advanced assessment needed o❑Yes-Type/Reason Inspection IimitationsSNone ❑visibility DAccess ❑Vines [Moot collar buried Describe This datasheet was produced by the International Society of Arboriculture(ISA)—2017 Page 2 of 2 IS11.. Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form Client -at/ t( Date (LI It' (7 0 Time 7 p,yt Address/Tree I cation l2(54 Si.s Caacr)�r, Z PL Tree no. Sheet 1 of Tree species teck C`ts dbh 2`7 7/)c_: Height 70 Crown spread dia. qS Assessor(s) . €C€411A{ ( r..c.. Sc,: ( 'etc. Tools used f i-' . i�ICrs,0{-,i; Time frame J Target Assessment aTarget zone E c c c Occupancy n. 3m � t d P P rate a c S Target description Target protection .§= ; 1 1 _t-rare ,s °t` _ N if LiO v Li0 es w =3�fie9�ent1 �.C C 4- f I- I 4—mnsbnt o.E c o. 1i iftL 1U 'AC,r �L. 2 0-e Nili I-e S� io 4 i7C% nc-, a )7e ?v 4 ln(; (I 4..; Site Factors History of failures t r-:. -j (1 Topography Flail]Slope❑ % Aspect Site changes None'5rade change❑Site clearing 0 Changed soil hydrology 0 Root cuts El Describe Soil conditions Limited volume❑Saturated❑,Shallow❑ CompactedEl Pavement over roots❑ 'i ; % Describe `;.�l.';c:�,.l(C 7 riez,x4 1;,c41 Prevailing wind direction Common weather Strong windSCrice❑ Snowddleavy rain 0 Describe Tree Health and Species Profile Vigor Low 0 Normal, '2 High❑ Foliage None(seasonallFL None(dead)❑ Normal_% Chlorotic % Necrotic % Pests/Biotic ru,},n� 1-4r,11.-^5 f Mi,�nru.if J (-- 14.4 Ole.Se Abiatic Species failure profile Branches❑ Trunk RootsFP Describe (2rc.i- i?c Load Factors Wind exposure Protected 0 PartielEPFull❑ Wind funneling 0 Relative crown size Small Medium 0 Large❑ Crown density Sparse 0 NormatU Dense❑ Interior branches Few Normal❑ Dense❑ Vines/Mistletoe/Moss 0 Recent or expected change in load factors Tree Defects and Conditions Affecting the Likelihood of Failure —Crown and Branches— Unbalanced crown 0 LCRFX) % Cracks 0 Lightning damage ❑ Dead twigs/branchesp- ( %overall Max.dia. `_ Codominant 0 Included bark 0 Broken/Hangers Number Max.dia. Over-extended branches 0 Weakattachments,B 11x, ,rt t-ir, nlr rS % Cavity/Nesthole circ. Pruning history Previous branch failures 0 Similar branches present'' Crown cleaned ❑ Thinned El Raised 0 Dead/Missing bark 0 Cankers/Galls/Burls❑ Sapwood damage/decay 0 Reduced 0 Topped 0 Lion-tailed 0 Conks 0 Heartwood decay 0 Flush cuts 0 Other Response growth Cirrrt Condition(s)of concern Part Size Fall Distance Part Size Fall Distance Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate Significant 0 Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate❑ Significant 0 Liktlihood of failure Improbable Possible 0 Probable 0 Imminent Likelihood of failure Improbable0 Possible 0 Probable Imminent —Trunk— —Roots and Root Collar— Dead/Missing bark 0 Abnormal bark texture/color❑ Collar buried/Not visible 0 Depth Stem girdling Codominant stems 0 Included bark 0 Cracks 0 Dead ❑ Decay 0 Conks/Mushroomstf Sapwood damage/decay 0 Cankers/Galls/Burls❑ Sap ooze 0 Ooze ❑ Cavity 0 %circ. Lightning damage❑ Heartwood deay❑ Conks/Mushrooms 0 Cracks 0 Cut/Damaged roots 0 Distance from trunk Cavity/Nest hole %circ. Depth Poor taper 0 Root plate0 Lean Corrected? liftingSoil weakness ID Response growth Response growth Condition(s)ofconcem Condition(s)ofconcem QG[�`i1i5iE+vv Part Size Fall Distance Part Size z� ��Lv Fall Distance 7 L'r Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate❑ Significant❑ Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 ModerateD%Significant 0 Ukelihood of failure Improbable❑ Possible 0 Probable 0 Imminent❑ Ukelihoodoffailure Improbable❑ Possible❑ Probable=Imminent❑ Page I of 2 Mi111 " City of Tigard r Tree Risk Assessment Form Hazard Rating: 13 IC. ' Probability 4 The et + Size of = Overall Risk of Failure Area Defective Part Rating Re pmmendedI.H, azard Tree Abatement Procedures: , . .vrt0t7'�Sl Ai-0 'f-rt-r' o.µcd tt-ti I-I'C-rP 4 e Lam/ e. `ke-e si-G r 4 0-e i h area ,J-5 m 1-kied Q fvt — Property Address: 1 Z I e4- S CO C es r<Sern Pt r Location: ❑ Public C4rivate 0 Right-of-Way Protected Tree: 0 Yes "sl%N0 Tree Species: 1)22d• ct'..k_ =i 1 Z Diameter at Breast Height(DBH): z7"'if.0 Tree Height: (..s2 Crown Spread: Lle' Tree Part Subject of Evaluation: +t'i6t I t' Diameter of Subject Tree Part: na 7 7/t D Distance to Target of Subject Tree Part LI-1 C Length of Subject Tree Part: (LA 4-•(--e 'T-t-e'P l Target:3t 11 rill re, Sc�elti'C; i k_ 1 Prr4--.1l.t:G.til pP,-4 rS-11-tr h S Co.s+6 ,,,.0 is r e.4.1t(4ayeev5 Occupancy of Target: ❑ Occasional Use ❑ Intermittent Use ❑ Frequent Use Constant Use Date of Evaluation: 1111 420 2 c_. Tree Risk Assessor. -em glot t Ceei C., ISA Number: ?n- (p c'y ,`+*A Tree Risk Assessor Signature: *Fill out this and supplemental rating fom omplJely and attach:1)photos of the tree;2)an aerial photo showing the location of the tree on the subject property;and 3)a supplemental tree risk assessment report more fully describing whether the definition of hazard tree has been met and,if necessary,recommended hazard tree abatement procedures. Appendix 1 t"" 1'� � i tt F r ar, a}a ' i "4} �r 1 r ;.,y. i f `'.' to . , 4, Y*-1 4.4t� 4.i" F .ti .' • .1. tM.y .w r , ^„wx eat,' X •f ,,ems .. Yl ' � f k V�e!;� � ,aft IT .. r •1 v�� li i /, 1 6 _i,::4 t �j Yy i 4.1' p 4:.t.' v� 6 'A'R7,.'''. a: •a''' '-'an 1 v ill `••``` _+iM _.{yj�.I �ajy:t .. e a l fin- .."F'`},'.. G '�'f i ' S t r 4. e .6F iNit l` , . . .- - ,..„_‘.,ipte,„... kiL- . . %. - - . _ A .: o ter•. k1/4 .9 - x A e � \ "ss r 1 ./ �.r • t1y T � . r iolp . s. 4j,t ', . .• .\ / • .`' \i t ' 4jrTa ..4t , ...of . 544 iiileke q - -, ., f y. „ p, ‘, • i ;,. :£' • Os ie. ite i Or Ili- Ft ;tir ,Y A,,. Vt ' , { '+T it 6 :7 ii 1 � -"�•isI It / /. p�C.,� ,__ `, e • A Af iy 7 Very sparse canopy,with lots of deadwood - ,, overhanging the arrow points at the large limb with a large longitudinal crack Arrow points at the broken central leader, numerous deadwood / and dying branches in the canopy. 011 'PAO MW Wx WO PON � � � � :f Adm.T 4 4� =vim_ i i„..t �.i nY. ,..tee.% M I. • 1( -_ cI ,.,„- � ' vo"1"-..,Aritt.. It, in "" 4111111AdV-7.-}V 7 74.''' '4111ktr' ''',' . _db., .01- ft. „ ,I /irk 'l `Q 11 I .4 !l , • yr,f I v'.. I. I \ ; � uy , ` n'3+;�,VA J 4 Apt r I`y�et/],fy' '< �!' .Z y f F I K. k i t<i., . ,.4 ti ;. .4 i r`;':• }� ,r , . .., , ( 04 ,3a � • R� g . ;Ira 4 - • L /qj I,f"g' ' 4- �' yy"nc?� yP( fir . F ir,ys "r i- , r N \ d cc�N �, � .r � .. r+ `�>'.7M' A•:-6 � �i,„- } 4R v d w i'y J • E+C , I '' T c Atli :::. � "rri aY E iltk4 _ J JF 1 �sy „. itHam. r •. y Y �'r kt 1- 1 ':r •, , ji ,;;,A,,NFJi ,} ; lh 1• I ] , .s;r. 1" , I�i ] 5 ik n, f . -.yn �Sr t `'e"t ' ___--- i ..j� I. i ,� 11q\ '�..4' C 3t t,% ' ' `." j A fj 1ju` .. •. _, . . 7-N....A'4.; ; ' ' • • •• , • , _, . •, •Ise.•,:•,? , ., ,..,•p... ''' I'Vft• .:,',,i, • , . .'.',I• • 1,,,, • ,, ••••'-' ,I,,/ :C-•-. , ''''..' ,r.1 -- \&''s i ;1 .ti •"''C' jilt'. # " ' t I ". "'l •"I,•;;• I . -., .,r, , . ;t4;;' 14:;:- ; ,:.,:;....!"..,..iti.,,,","--,, _ 1' - . 16,,, ,,,,,, ..,,. . • :,, . .. ‘, ,.....,,...•., •- aI.)1.4'' 4..!;,••',I''I,I''I:,.1..1'.‘.1 ',..' . .1 4 .. ;•.. •':k'-c .• ..f.l':.:"i:,2,;,...',!•. • . '' P , . : ' f 1 ,,.,. '. •• • 1y :1-,•.„-) ••• • 7! •-• • ''' •f.: • :'‘- ' • ii,•41 .,4Nio. ;' • - .4,, t ."-- -1 ,,,... . .'o ,L'-:, • .7.. ' 4-411.:'g`040..v , - , .,. . ' VLS'1 ''''••.• . ''4•••'f:"• 1 • • • I '. ',4/ -,,J. ''' •'.,..4. ' '. ;.41'... - • ;- '' ' 41, f:•i: ...„ z,,,,,.) - ,..-u.„... .. . ,.44' • .' „e. ,"=.......,f-l'• • . '')it.- . ' :..t1 /% 4, : ' ft:p — "' -' • • :4Vt/ ki;,, ...-... :.,..4 j !; ,, ..:st..,- . •-„'--' .- ''•,. ...S1'' ; ..;-;.• te'. , ' -' '- ,.4 :CA.,,;•• ', •Li.-,,,-.1f;',.f. .ti-.../.,.. , :,.. .•!,,, ; r . ..,,!".,....,,.,. ; i',..,. . • „ •••, .•14.•ti , •i.i,?••' Z t '.I:'' •14i'rrer 'L / - ' .•• ' ' '('-'-• ,•ii 7'4' :.I I 'lf' l . ?'''•i :•'?-:. '.%',1 '', .-3 t:. ' . '•• . ,.,..,..*`,- ,... . , , „li t A 1 .-.? .f;,,0 At''':',! -'..,..ei, . ,...1. ''..,•,;,r ..... ' - ' t-;t , il E-1..L.,. ,'$,'-- ••• ;r,f 1 .?$,..::::44( 0 1. ,' -'.,, '..tr.1,‘ -'4:-..s:...,.. ''‘''`.7 k' - -.• " - ; .4.' 'yr,' ,f " .-4, L ,.4. , . ' •, ..0../.• ''', "I'' P."...1 .." •• ,••'S ....., • . "I 11' •' ;I,' '. t'" 'V • - '• 14. ti4A-2...,;;- rit- .4 X• '"e•\'.:. .. -14.', . - . ‘,1 . ,.*;44..,: ....),•ri„o... i,11; • ar.,'-' .t''''''',V ' - t.. , .p.. !`-,f',,:.?. .t.4-' okh!), .., '--'''..,..',1 1 1 ' '''''. ; " ..'Y .', •..0.°•' •-,4-,,4:,.",..-.., ,::k-tl's-:i• ::•••-`,-;61,141P . '. :: t , d" .4.-,:.;!.. --,:' • i•-• . 1 cro,..•..f.-- t. .,,. •+, ' .., "..5."':•;''1"'"'' .P'`:;"• •?." a ,t1-Vt"....."9.&". ‘"ri':"' " " P. ,4 : . • :. - sl,x- ,-,! t", . .- ,•t tii, ,.., :•,,-...,.: - . . ,, I.:R....',Iff.04.-i..,-4,-,,,,=.,,,, ,,:v 4 .-4).'.e.: -.41,-,-.., • -I, .,,.,, • •it . . -. ' ..-. ,•/ i --4--:-,?.-4,',.• ...- ..xs*1 ;14.1 .P1-:11-'' ' 4.— ' of.o, i •'-' ' ' 1 . 'T'''2'-'.' ... ' ,?A, • I' L'i ‘..e.,i' '' .^..:1 ....-.1.1 ...i.'_'.-ve-4;?:-: '.- ,)., • %;‘‘.,:..••.1,..„, •.-...v, .1‘2, ''. -- , f..n:47,,,,,vs '-,..i..,7k:- ,.. ,,t", . ..N., ,..,„‘•-4,:4 ' ..1 .4.... . • : • ,:.:' '..?Ei•'y, ,:-p-•tr,)••••• i ',..,1'-‘,,k•04:::' : ' .0 t; • '-.II-. '04. ,.'• ...t •-7 ' • '-. A. l......."1, 111-...1x....,. 0,-- ir. ' •-.";""Nii162"Fft??4, ..••• • • , . - •,. • • • ' J .+.I '''''` - ••••' ', P 1*41 .11. k41`.44)4 ,,•' ''• .6: ' ' ' '''' - .'1...v. i.,tx .. •- 4•2.1 :".• •-;i,,,-.•.- --,-- tt e...." '1` • a. i•''''. ' ''A': • ' r; ‘•""..k.r""''' ....T.','...' ;-''' If.. ..gr''''1 04•-017,,H-4::4"..,•`-''''''''' .. --,!-::' ii.. ...'1,,,Lf.......;:-.',---10--';',.. ....,,f-..-. •.47 IV P-41.111"%.k,*;•-,.....,A4 •,• • 05' ri-t• '' - .." •', ..,..,;" 0.- - -1 X";'' ••••- "; •A''' '• ' ...t" . -- A r.-3- :44".4,-tr? ,,. - I, ' ', •,-.'-,:d '"r - ,-.0,4"..;;Pi:4,,,,•440,,,44:,3*.e#4.,,-.t2„.00433.4.444::,., , ;•.-;,' "'''.•' 0`-';'_rsk4t•C•r.....'L...' -' ;',„14 • It .'-..... — ' d' " ".• .dti'.'''A.14' '..74 F. . •1 ',1...E1- -. -1 • , .. * ,„.1,'11•%>,L.:r ill. .U.' ..114. xik, • 4 A 4„,,4_...,..3.74,,r,,,,..„.,,,, ,,,. ..„4,1„.4,10„..t. , ,,,.. ,,,, .,43-.- ; e:,:,„..,, . ,.,..ra,la.'il •'VNilitirl 4 V ,.,-,i.740. 1--feArv- „ego 11.1. " ,...-- ,,,,,, --, ,.,, - -,• •' -7.., $.4•,c-,,,5•5••••••••. ••••• '•••• ,,,*.3;4 Orr • •A ",d'.., ..,,, '.4 .'..10,, ‘.. :,4' II"r.S.", ,• A",'''4, rift Gt 4 ••••;11::* ,A*, 'PT.•, ' rf 1 ‘..er.3: ",,,,f.• - ...•':, irr/ .D'S.:,rr 4 t .4, ..?, ,..,,„,„„wa;,, Jo ,,,,. . t . .4-.4, , .,.-.v.; • •- -• --.; ..! if ..„. . „ , 4 •:,' u •;*:* 1410:nt ` • ,.... • A`;$-V• ••'•" `• •' . — • • • I *.st1/4 #0A . 6'n -- ,••.4:4$,-,. 9. ;,' • " •.E-•-01.,ia.,,..v ,,,t-* • -,4 4;1%.:.,,,..- , „,t's, If 4.4:14, • k,-,c,,-1.0rkk .AFte, . ri 1 ,, N,, tk I , • \'4' .P47.4•' : 4 • r-4,4" ..%!Var. ,-r--17-`4 - &A.,-4•'' ..., .,,.. .1, - ' 4 4. ':-....1-: 1 . ....s,'•:...tt. -1.'''":,A--.74,,,-,:lik'',., t:. 11,56.-r. ....;',-...! -6 • •'. .. .••-+,,' ' , 4,1q,e.10'..41., ,. % •f , -- ". -,"..,, .' tt!'•'' •141',-4•5•3•,--;4.ti•••11.!4174..0...r. i .40:•,;•:; •....... :•4•,.-1.?....", ...•*-.‘,1; :•,..-,...,•,•• * `. i 1 4"•„*.,* l':•!‘ , ikkt, ,,•'1 it 'if : •:: .•• .....0•10t • ,,Ifft..,, r.....:..-1.i,e•9,:k.:!•'4.1,co,,,t,•„it.: ...._,„.. .....• • • .4.!-:.---:0.,. -re• . 1214, ''' `‘'1`°'4r.i' 41/k Z t 'i, ,••••".../4,443;,':2•044••••: "t',4PF-;',.7te‘• ."..r'EilistrP7"v›,-;.1i, gAller31.4. ( 47,0‘1,1• .,4;1;1: . . 'co, •td;:t .. ,:,.p.,..-/,,.-•-,., , „„,4-.7-J,_.‘,...14 ,,., • ... „• .•.: il,.,.t, „, ..... ,,11....l . ••• ,i.t. )I. , • A'•-•'111.1",. Al '''•••"/.-.'17 f....-.•1 ..or 4 4 _.' ‘ 2 4 4-,-,4.2- 1,„. ...f .,•,‘ 0..,i.../. .;„t.fir. ,, .1.1.:., . 4..,:y...4.:,:v.,..,.... ...,...1,,,,-..4,..xv„ kt ..,... •,,tr•.,. -4. ..,,4•?. , . • • ,.....,, ,..t.. *sit:'• '4 ' •-'' - -4•'4' +• 1,..,:,' 4f-'1,k ti,';'1.,1 ** `;-'-'11".:' ' ,,;••/;,,k1 -:' .,, vp.,,,,,' , - •', . e4.1V- , :` . '-.'':'•‹—:- ..; u„..-.,.;#41;`,:l.'')r-;;;;,-4.' N.: .„ .,:, i._ ,,:- -.,,,.. 1N-,4,is) :, ,,,.4, , :,,y,t,e 4,,, _....,#:!,,..7-4;,„.... •4.. .1" .' ',,,' tr*.d 1 t', :.: ,.-1 r ' - • . '.54:.L1it*A.f ' At .., V ....‘" ' e' 4, .14.. ' '4-'R'' •---/. , ..!r,,,.-7:',. .v.,' - , , .t.t!i?4? -.:k41, ii, .11i a 4', 'vo' C ? t..A .;'""..'' ---ret'ATV. "' 'f'? ''.. '' I ''. :.".•• "4-4 ""..".. i *, 4," ..1 ,tz ,,. ,-:, • ,pv, .,.., , •+..." • , `' t4 ak'4 LI>:' . ' , :t4d.• , r :.'`,';'; V.44`16.4„$, 1"Y: , 4...03.idt*.cue1 4 1.: "'' '. ori .. .•ST`715.4...ik.Z 'V(' :7„r.: 1, `.1-,... .*'2, ."',..'::'•::-.7. n.. -.. ',c;.? .•:)7:4;e•T:.•:r.• Z*11* . ' ,. •1,:t •,. , , 6 i .. %VON.t.A •i:.,, , '-', .•"41.••-.. ....''.. '1 '. ' !. , S" 4' ".'' 4' ''. • V."• ' `,..1.0.I r.D. ,. • rt. 4 3. 7. d"/ 134:1'..g....ste If ti V., • ,4.: ,• ”:„. ...., '''4 ' , r.,f,, I ,, , ‘,,A A .' =7' • •L-,,,',1":fly. 'c-4. . :fr., : '0,'4' •'Pp.,' 9."1`14''r74. i'li•A,...-- -- .• xp,.., ... 4.,,,,, . ,.; • - v „ 1... • . . , *.,., • k. •Sk..,.'41r •'. * A ...-0 1".•• .4, -.• .,•, A.•• ,•.t.$4. , • -• .. ,... •., .....,, -••,•4 4 . • • • `..1.1 Ir. A'AO ..: 4 . i- qv; • '•, •,t.= ••, • k i.er. ...4.0---.. r„, Nr A, _A:1' • " 1' " lie•_,_i I' ,t t',...:•...7 . . N•;-•1 ts`-.i ' . : . : ,) '. 1 ..# 4. 44 r4r44.....,,, ,,,,,,t, ,. ., 4-.rg.435...,..1.-tr,.-17..„-,,,,=,,, :.,?=.r , ,,;.-- _t_el- .,.:-.-4014.‘ tt.: ). "'' '.... ---.."4: •••":"" '0.''•.?;• 3-,-,•.,ezt-••• wor,„': . .._.j;-, . •••• ''v`,pf,•`.10*-r'',4-qk7.. „ , -Mt, i, z. , ,• ' .., ) ."*.rk'„. : ,,-, 4 !. -••••:;.•••,.-• • Op w":4 • rr ..s:D' ..,I.:..t - C.,4•••.,,•1... -...,.-'....N,A..'i"t a• '' • ‘3i;"'1ft" iVs. ..I.v'tt":'.'kSJ‘ •-k •::.D 'k .' ' ''' - * - +..414 E 4„,,s:'•.••,•„•.r.4111•e•I.i,1A, ,.*P,,ylt• .y.., 0... , ' . 1 17--• ,.....„.•,•••••••4t:• .•• . " -1..c4" • V• -"J.'' 4 " • '.D'4... A],. ' ' . 1..!'3". ''''-'°"•••i•i,.. 'D'''. .....'...X.D. . . . D.' .7:.. Qat°.r art.,.' ..,, ‘ • . . s.'•V i ..1 . 'Ati.'•-• --.A.•,•t -".' . `-. ---- -1°-•••:• i344f11 •`•• 4 . . -it,,,,- $ .• - - If'''4' Av„.•.•,. • • t,' k't Zlici-4:.''''.'s'2• , •••••"-• "'Ai',•.ia,.." -A..* -•••;;,,,A,„,..,?''''' 4,!..,r'..." • ,,,.. ,"•• ..._ „ - ,zk. -•,.. .=Z;- - • , k, t - 4-: •••• - , y,X" • I..)."2"‘Al •"•f• *:07,4!':...• '. ':' ..x. -•••••••• IL'4•11.' V0;71." '-1 •• 1 ' 'ZN'- Z ''''•4 ". i 4 `..i ... 6k.,1 )4_.-..gv"VAlfa.;;;•`;ik-,...14.f.t.' ' :'1- f ' • d'l..;-.Alt•. ., _iid41A a IL C'"' .-11...4 .-• 4 . -1.* 1 • . ' a a.-"ea-4.•,-.• - 111.60C4-4.i ki" .ta• ' . ..,••••WOr 11,'V,. A . .1.4 , . 0/4 ...k.a.., •4 ......,.....,/ . .... . ' .. ..!' •..ilk. Is 4 •F '-.1.. •••'1••,•ie 14'. - ••••1- ••: •"'•.• nt; V.. ... ..1 • . ‘410Airi ',.../.... Yk..^. ••• . \' . . ^"iLt1/4..4%.", -.. ...'4.• • '' - '‘ -- ;• ' -i *414•'• t Ji.r....:.: •:-'44. ::..410.•7 '.•.14,4,3•441'. . ,.. . : . * 4. ....V. :::..4,.. .":42-2...:.17.::::4e.j,.••• ir..!....... ...•••...4V '''.:*/.....4.°2„,....ii.'`'..t. -"' .:.;f'1'.... Z'. ' ..1 4' 4,4a4.- .. . •. v.v.\ , . • ,-. 64,. . f,•-: ... 4,4. '--,fig. , '..‘;.C.• - .'. ..* .•-1 ..,:. .vg:As 1. -44' - ...., ;.... .... •" I 4".4 '" -.• '''' '.' 44. .• ..t N•qh. •.,V,5,• Vo_,;.,..4- ' i *•,',.,t: .. ..• . .:., ., .4•,::;").",,,•••••• 4,'.16c ' .•• lx ,c4i ••,^%-• - • '' t ' ts --- -. .1-z, o...-kgt, ‘',..:ZIts'.. '•,*- 1, • _. •• -' :•••,!,..,. 4- ''4. • ,-.,.• '''=`.11 +,•:*.i '--.• - -- ' NV...,...!-.; •-•-• :.•1•.. 1,-.. '..,‘„,' ..'„A e).4...t.- - •s•- , ; , , H \A,,;,. tt.*. ... .!,. *.,. — ...I.,..„ .. ., -,, ! 1 - .!: 1kr:-:(41,..,, r •c• „,:i .). - • •- -'! t• . f.•N- '''. .--,-,....,,,,,.,4. D. •I rg '''Si. . ."t"./L tr. 41C...':Ali 'D *t."... "•"-.034 • -..tf: ' ' ' 4 7.'""','"`" -;`, "P",,...c.• • r . ,.. • . i. 11., '..• ' ...IPIX.tAt . • . • ..0.1.-, .-.P.,14'LI...e-gir 44, " r_.... " .'.- ---,' 4, .. - •••4- Risk Categorization Likelihood Failure&impact Consequences Failure Impact Target Condition(s) (from Mrem,iI (Target number Tree part of concern a al E Risk desaiption) A a uc3 E > = au u •: E ratingo NaE -2u3 m _ ErZ m ° c u (from a a: E > j i'u 2 3 N f N N Mo6x2) ‘.111iCt'e5 Ltrc-Lao- i—;,rac Ltd ?c% N P,,'' 11h ;de+�rti6lC/tom k+r� X u . h;cle d G^Gc.lcke.4 VircalCIO ,-- ?r--" ti 7(-, Jflifla Irtl.aCVI Qa&- f'�u `nS is r3 1 tO+l P ce5 Rt..7 OD Swci-Vi'+ -C-C.2.ltct.-‹ X 1 1iP1' t.l: V }c Matrix!.Likelihood matrix. I , I Likelihood Likelihood of Impact _ of Failure Very low Low Medium High Imminent Unlikely Somewhat likely Likely Very likely --- Probable Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat likely Likely Possible Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat likely Improbable Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely , Matrix 2.Risk rating matrix. Likelihood of Consequences of Failure i Failure&Impact Negligible Minor Significant Severe 1 Very likely Low Moderate High Extreme - -- - - I - Likely Low Moderate High High Somewhat likely Low Low Moderate Moderate North Unlikely Low Low Low Low es^`"""`�<.,}s Notes,explanations,descriptions fff✓ �4 i i to r•,,,-1 tTr 1 ()i e tact k 1,S t'(:tclt%Y1 ee Li' � f� �t" Rot) -,w a n1fi, i?Y>in� i!LL l'LYh FenC;1--t'c�l "{et kJ;t/ t cZd 'l r / Ret�t tY1.;,.ACLK6(2_Ptt1Al tnr vr41-3- Mitigation options;� 1. C Q.I.V\C`n 1 Ct`l Residual risk 2. Residual risk 3' Residual risk 4' Residual risk Overall tree risk rating Low 0 Moderate 0 Highn' Extreme❑ Overall residual risk None fl Low 0 Moderate❑ High 0 Extreme 0 Recommended inspection interval Data ElFinal ❑Preliminary Advanced assessment needed ❑Yes-Type/Reason Inspection limitations ONone ❑Visibility DAccess ['Vines ❑Root collar buried Describe This darusheet was produced by the International Society of Arboriculture(ISA)—20I7 Page 2 of 2 ISA. Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form Client P(i f 71 7 Date (III i k47r., Time -. �, Address/Treel�ocation 1Z.154 S).t.: C-►r~rdrr, P1 Tree no. ..3.....3... Sheet of r Tree species ed CXLIC dbh (?i f i - Height 50 Crown spread dia. '-a.',' Assessor(s) L)PrP...t,i (F�ac,. ,�c ) .:rPdC., Tools used Di? -k - n,�c1-FI� et Time frame 1 Target Assessment Target zone v a c c Occupancy p- rate g m c_ c 'target description Target protection 1 n „ i 2-occasbnal . ,i$ m e:5 e.. eAi 3-frequent Up u tg As F sm H 4-constant E E o&c a 1 liC�'1�Ci{r� P . 11 nC_ Cl(+.,. 2 P1'6;?l0 ie-' G{ +It: y'1C.. 3 (ch i rv, !G 4 )'tD ;IL, 4 J Site Factors History of failures Lib C: Its I)'),nl I ,l i. ,.C Topography Flat❑ISlope❑ % Aspect Site changes Noneradechange❑ Site clearing Changed soil hydrology 0 Root cuts 0 Describe Soil conditions Limited volumeMsaturated❑ Shallow❑ Compacted 0-Pavement over rootsizf 7(i % Describe 1-+^ee. i5 In cL Prevailing wind direction Common weather StrongwindsEl Ice❑ Snow HeavyrairyC Describe t•'rL'rt ST"Pi i5Kcc4 Tree Health and Species Profile Vigor Low. Normal ❑ High 0 Foliage None(seasonal)Er None(dead)❑ Normal_% Chlorotic % Necrotic % Pests/Biotic I Abiotic Species failure profile BranchesEiTrunk❑ Roots 0 Describe Load Factors Wind exposure Protected 0 PartiatL7 Full 0 Wind funneling 0 Relative crown size Small Mediurn❑-Large❑ Crown density Spars Normal 0 Dense CI Interior branches Few formal❑ Dense 0 Vines/Mistletoe/Moss 0 Recent or expected change in load factors Tree Defects and Conditions Affecting the Likelihood of Failure —Crown and Branches— n 4C4. Unbalancedcrowng LCR 35_% Cracks ,--.,. -I-,,r{;ne,k h.tncit C( Lightning damage CI Dead twigs/branches R ')-& %overall Max.dia. 4" Codominant❑ , Included bark 0 Broken/Hangers Number Max.dia. "2-, 4" Weak attachments.- Cavity/Nest hole%circ. Over-extended branches i7' Previous branch failures xa,r••,,,•,:u', Similar branches present❑- Pruning history Dead/Missing barklEGCankers/Galls/Burls❑ Sapwood damage/decay 0 Crown cleaned 0 Thinned ❑" Raised 0 Reduced 0 Topped El Lion-tailed 0 Conks 0 Heartwood decay❑ Flush cuts 0 Other Response growth i c.:r..i +11,niwr..A Conditipn(s)of concern I nu w+L+- .( %'I t l r l- "1' t •i ibl P, he.? / L n.� }t.rl ire.l f)Y�,;. a /', �. l�i'o<1 C. .l p• M'( i v o�. Lam? Part Size ( 7� Fall Distance Part Size >'' all Distance + l-t.'-.1- 4-t Load on defect N/A❑ Minor ❑ Moderate❑ 5ignificantOD Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 ModerateC) Significant El Likelihood of failure Improbable Possible 0 Probable 02Imminent❑ Likelihood of failure Improbable❑ Possible 0 Probable p2lmminent❑ —Trunk— \( —Roots and Root Collar— Dead/Missing bark 0 Abnormal bark texture/color 0 Collar buried/Not visible 0 Depth Stem girdling 0 Codominant stems 0 Included bark❑ Cracks❑ Dead 0 Decay❑ Conks/Mushrooms❑ Sapwood damage/decay 0 Cankers/Galls/Burls 0 Sap ooze❑ Ooze 0 Cavity 0 %circ. Lightning damage CI Heartwood decay Conks/Mushrooms❑ Cracks❑ Cut/Damaged roots 0 Distance from trunk Cavity/Nest hole_%circ. Depth Poor taper 0 Root plate lifting 0 Soil weakness a-' Lean ' Corrected? Pit•' Response growth Response growth Response isegrofmncem Cordrhon(s)ofconcqrt Ct1+Ifr, *.e.4 crt- Ss(S4-eMt Part Size Fall Distance Part Size e;'t- tv'c- Fall Distance 5-45 Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate Significant Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 2Moderate❑ Significant Likelihood of failure Improbable Possible 0 Probable 0 Imminent 0 Ukelihood of failure Improbable❑ Possible Probable 0 Imminent❑ Page I of 2 Ilq c! City of Tigard e,t .. Tree Risk Assessment Form Hazard Rating. 4 / 9 ProTability + The Target + Size of = Overall Risk of Failure Area Defective Part Rating Recommended Hazard Tree Abatement Procedures: nn karn0O cuA,d RA.,ILcic;.te ,An( A -art cr.?: r yt, + t ccJnA V iT) rit:Q Property Address: (ZL554 SL ) Get(-Ith PC Location: 0 Public ,rivate 0 Right-of-Way Protected Tree: 0 Yes "o Tree Species: e.e8 a L 42— Diameter at Breast Height(DBH): (C iI its Tree Height 'I,O 1 Crown Spread: l*�i` Tree Part Subject of Evaluation: l,134•‘0��.1 - C i'cvJ1, — Qoeyt Pic, - - Diameter of Subject Tree Part I'ell Distance to Target of Subject Tree Part q-lot Length of Subject Tree Part —1 5 t Target: U-ikcAec A (-4 cirq)I h2. S1c ,9tcr,Ik , !a/Kin1) 2cxc-4, ru5tcsuo;S curd-kit ficq-Ce5 Occupancy of Target. 0 Occasionals Use 0 Intermittent Use 0 Frequent Use Constant Use Date of Evaluation: (l J i / Zvi Tree Risk Assessor: , „d,(&n Sae.t,c,e ci U ISA Number: Pn- 1a" Tree Risk Assessor Signature: *Pill out this and supplemental rating form co t rely ch:1)photos of the tree;2)an aerial photo showing the location of the tree on the subject property;and a supplemental tree risk assessment report more fully describing whether the definition of hazard tree has been met and,if necessary,recommended hazard tree abatement procedures. Appendix 1 • ••c\ `...". .��.r ty A'X`A ., j�MMN`•• ;�r�h�`J i- • .a-• . V. ,� 'On� •( vy 1-r,IT.�f ' . { z.-,...600,rrai}�M�9f� -. , t q! +.r'Via^ .S 3'4.' n~ A•�T.",SFM ' ; r' "4 ral }}MM IJ r - rAer `i.;•t M� ix � `q,.. ya ur. i v § R� xC! +1 i` -t ,0K }!;t.�E'Y ..� �. r .... "$S ° • rsF• .,afy,.`. YFs;` CT-4) i7��yT4.st:K: cj I .•. ,..7!'t " A t� t�..'r• '4..7,i ��' .,t,. 73 ), a r ':•• • rr y ♦r'.J_.. \t , .r. ram.+'? 1�: te r."1•.. t`�v{N.`i • ....r`?.*.'r_. f•' T`.1 N'�gVL{i YT= c .'r- ). (`y'� '� � '.✓��+v�_ ham ? Y°tils. .. v.. .jY.. ./ r '?'v 3N..+'Y...r ht'fi.v1S...Fes'.a s ��x ti�•1 C �e'4`yPa F r ... Infrastructure damage to the new curbing. c w :1.......... .. s '� =- • r. .. '•F�1']��4�°� ° ,ak.:4 ��y"c�' 'w:.V.�5f . y1"!C.•{'N'e�"F. 1:r7..4.14' r'`r 1.' .�ri� l( +" . . L.,. �'t� a;`�x.✓:i' °4• 1°.jQ b`�' 7?`w 7 `ti...� h lost: y.•q✓. uu 'S' •'.J yv.y `t nh, {q.,y'. i 4`4')(V4.,•.a `- "•.-) H VI"-,,' 4'k e 4:)--, :r..,,•: kili.•Vr....4 •-,:;4...47...„ 4. •, • ",\IItip( o ^ :, •.. e. &s i t . C. -•;- t ..s 'f . r :�. ��!a t1_ i • �L1 Gi ./. yt a c. ct ^vr.r ;-..a 17 r • 1 f ? may-.! '� • ` `�` T .� 1, 1r J ' _ ' J • 11. Y , 'C 1 _ tIhr .l U., f' :IA JrY #.w�,— S ,) • �(.. /t F .,ram r ' f'f .*". `. , S w<i .- 7 t _ , ..' + 1 ti ♦> 1° � Pk II •I• 1 K d SY::XL+'+i7.ar ,.,.... F _' "2`�` 4 • Q s r yam, �, `/ ! 'S'JiYrY'�aw.. Yi:.{70. -i �; �' + Y f �YI�'- • . , ;= r . N,N Y W '' mr. 6 n° fit ` ',..e•• 'Y L`� �� -— �� 'A 5' �1-3--- ��a%.- . , . .. * • - . , . . -11% ."..< 10,.... , • _, •• 1,7'0.- ,,-* , -*.-- - : ,. e, - '''.-.i.fr. --1‘. • .... ' - , r • )..\ . • •• a 0, %Ai .i _ , -ir :".„....... _. i ..u...........„. ....." V qp gp.- . . - . . —• dirAllW vs slirffiliti-1;-.14ittt ....„ - row ikk- rAllifitilg=8"-4.ttti -, .-„,...141/40..„0,,, . - . ........ Ori -7. *‘4111ftfile.t.'"'•li itV111111,0 lik14.' \.,,,4,111r,:r . ..t • ANI*-- itii.A.t141, :„‘,„_441\,,,„,.11,411_ Fasittiwr. ,.,, \IAN** *, \\". T.,41, m„.,.-,. . • .. nt- • Y •.? , . I 4111 • 'r,— 10..cm,,,.._ ar„„ki 4• • - I\ '.. : ...'‘i . - 1 ' - ' 1;1117114111k ,,,, o, ,_ , , P*,-.. ,. • . '-•A. • VA' ‘,- ' kti,,,,,,,;:.. nill4.."66.11‘1101‘ V \ !Aillik _. a45 .0, ZOO r i 1 . ._.... ,, ,v,),,,,„--r-. •-„, • , .. ,, ...16, ,.,7_, gift-- wt. ;r,.• tif, ".../ ..?.... - - ..,, .t'i.,4,:oz„k"..2tor y . •- - i ........ .. • . ._......_,..orozoill.,Ail., • Artio . -," - vetz-44mr---*A4 ,A v 4 • . 1.:6.-....- ,___ 0.----ek •••••.::,4, A ‘ • . 71 ', . - ‘,-.N1k. 4.th- -%hilL• f.,lei....itt‘ Abl • . .-AM.'.At. .44414: • ' - '- ' A v ...9743011, •:,-,. .-s. - iiiiirir.:1/4 . vi,407 ....... 4 rrliFt,_ idt*" 4iik. . 1 ---. 3r,,,,. •zw. tkie* .- ....ft, ,. v .., _- .... ...kli • . , • r • ..... Ili ;;;i1*;4.,. ; /2.. . .., .. . ' IV i .'" ' .:.:1'i, viIi r i 41 ‘. •'' 0 il -' ' Att . .. .. 2,, . • , • v,Li . .f- - . i , .. •_ , J. -':' 14 Central Leader is in steady decline (see arrow) { . _ . •C.-. '• „'.•, • . t• - ...ww• --4 1 .„1" _ .1 6 ' diiii3Wif VJ.-----....., sr=WE 6..._-;.::::.I..':• ---- .-C1 ;. - , 4.. -. . ".- ...- .--, tv., . 46.. 1 -a••• . = le . 7.--- .z..... .:.....—_, ,....,.,--..:,-;*,e. ;,-, . — .„. . , - , _. . ........ -. -. . — - ,,i•. ,....„.-: -4"4-5.... iierro, — -..----r•r*.L-'-.... '--= ,.-&._•,:.. *:,;:r1.- - - .— . - - 7.-:-.... • — '— ,...- * .--- - - '-`*----`"I'''.4'774:" 7?....^0. . , - ca. --.-...,;=,--1 -''''..'--*,*,--- -:-------4'.1*-4`.-- - • -- -- - .. ," ittl,,,t...:..„1, --a- --,;;"--..,-.•—•=4. ,.% ,4:-...: ,. -,,..405.0.-.S. ,k.--_---, ._:-.....,-D-v---:-----• .. •- -0.,..4, • .., -,--_ ..,, .t•.-,..;•,-2.- -- • _ ....-:gr:::,....-.- t_ -1.1..4a.. . .:...A1.`57-%&---• ..-___:,--- - ._• - • - , t . Ill N�� . - vEr.,,.. i, .. a . ::;,titt`• — AS 0 k..'=-1-;.' .- ' '- 16110P;iLgtie:444.04kk: , . i‘Z.....„ . ' litt wai. d VV '�• % � _ i! 1 oii fir, p 'i;�•! N •�ll� 1 .�ei, rAiy-�,.°'1�� ,. lori , 6llor ;''� •ate r M1� 0,..„ fir Otr: -v. 7 :• - 1.1�'4�° Wi lt }l.y, Y Sys•«,f-Ora.-.;:0f 7 4 r 11 y '�i`. iv1i ii r jr.,oi 4 A !rE N/)`10 %OP• (/.l. V<a?o:_i1 7• / 45141 711 1 li/. t44 `qV 4.....4"..•..,4,i 4la,,1 \." .,.-4 ,-, 14 .0,-, ,. ,- .. .,: .,„.0•,..- ,. . l' t OP' Y57. - 9,1)Attl. "Ii.:', ,y-a,Ir �f. cige ti r t. •.i ', ! s , .,,{ .ti ,F'_�� vim"V:16 '1' . 1 litt.if, ‘1' ...44VA11.0:„:".:.'.1.:„.4,444, ' ' At,...‘,;. .,t;;4 it,Z4410,11,1P a.$.p .ic.,., . ' /,6 i rt./ i ff. Ir 144.: el'- 1' 1 :NF# l ' a I 1 AJ1/f(/, s ii ,‘{ 'ft 4 7 1 J( lkir:81+1,44ViAtk\*A it./ Ai. 1 FeAh .L4 W i„ , I 01...•,4 .1 .,.......-06,.,41. (.....4, g.,...,,.., ,, ..--"-416-4NIINg-0, 4 4eillic tiOrS .E ' .5,0-4, %. e• w.d•1 ( ° 11. Lik4&- Ai Afar, ' . or- - , of kok4.4,51 .:-....• v-... ,,....1 i or 1 *It tip.%•40/ --it !, 4,:g ......41,,, r z.a,°1' ..14 404 A„. 41 .. .••••%ek iki."fp I taw ,,..i•4.4...,,t41/ Ifzer ...•,titj"F lit, 11‘,W, • ,gfor Ival ''4'k% 1:1Villetifet• d%11.4 ! - 4 Wi rP6W 4 r 04#4 kkr-e•..i,I lit‘..\ i 111 .. ft $ •E \/ - , - , . vivo If r ' A 4!ti i ALA, ?. 1 ',,-_:.•••. / .: v. rf 441 ifid i 4 K1v it t li i lk 4ii Apo ; re-PA -,... itwv4; N44. k,. 1 or - <t ,4, , im„ qk It ` - 'V.\ t . ilkt 50,0, •.:,-.'-:.11.•,F„4.-'1....1.1.;..-.i 4\,f 44"r1„,"-'Wfr.4,%--1ivVk1..-1A4:.-r t4.V's.'t0‘'i.f,cal-rk 4,.i1 A .4kA\ tirii•4„/,-t1. k •M.Ilp.(Iv 1glii Fp AI(0..t 1'f kt. ,1k s-. 1k 10 • rt4gr 41;4_°,PA g7y24vdt164 1de 1 4-1,'7#/i 6 f/4-44-d0r‘-r0A;-/-T11O-.41$1"."4,.a 1 4;'•W1,,41,.,VArA.,,.'e•.,6'.,a 1 4 l I e. 14 e I P"m,Ir.,t/i,i.ri,iti*,fli lltai•N",r;i..,%e.',..L k.rW-)..? iAla. a \ .‘- lip ... Tip si -.%tor.4____,AlsahNNisk,.% tout tut vi, i r . . "r 44i ,a • so klib. lre , i'fr ..-or ..... -v iAy f-,,, 4.1/4 •- r v it 40,...,_ wollip...-/ 4iv e,-/gtoit..„ \- ".1p.-'21111117 14' ‘;•‘ Aeiv • 441.1iDaikiti!`"4- • , \-, 'At' --..,... Alb, •41-..'4;.; 4 '4040"2 4 t- . '''' )1 4i. ... figfaltirlra...441101411V, fth ' 11'.' :A ;.;, , -"',,r,t Aytook.'W.,,t,"14 -- - • 4......"' -.10 al -V1 ,,. -4 Ls, .-•vp& -,.: k..„ ..40- . ,,,,, ,,..... r ' lif .111' ‘ F. (01,4., ..fsg KIP m • .'4.--,-.•N,.:.e4L• ;4*i,;.*,1.'P A4,\1.t,co-t1..,-A•::,i-,tA'.A-.-, ': 4,.-c l 14 k1k"'a.1 l;iV4t.10 t4 f.IV zi4.ff-&0i-1 A N $•••fr ...,....-...,, - i ,A,: • 4_•,.i4'1,44.-,,.-_1-„.P.3* 4 . i-. 0 . w, 0 ; . -e_. • h1.4r1•t 64i14 ,,. •- V 10-4.11-.1F7- if , , i„,,v).4—' • i, \\‘,.. —,70;,vil A ,,.. •\ VA. �_3 ({ \rs f '�' ..+y. � �zyx.,.. r +,ar�-�•.r.Y ..,-r''XA- 414"• �Y�. �ay.f ` • . / "Fri/a^Y'CrN r+. C � s rv. s ,� T ` F 5 aL �t:y L } ° �v 5�7 � tlY � {d�_ �+ y' �w hv� , a-- y •.� I . `, y f /Oi-2r ' '{3 .'(yam�� .re:., ,�,{'r"[�^'`t""'s_ + ..r if I .>•� x�, 1� !• .S•`, ` rl jF ..T ; •!• `,,,yG. 4• ^'6y'.r"_�-y^-t •. 1 a , .. {. ),,-, 1 / • J t pp ;1. i.. r k..e'' Ty it 4�"" ��• h i. Fad'4...0,.... h fi. .i .,�'�j ti 1 i �, W irse r. g 1 {{ 1, f''ti r'',r'}i u.",`<.ref- •4 ", f. @ u'�v ).... rv1 c. '<� • . . . • /� ' _. /CIS f. s .`.la !'� � r!{" + • .f"- a "J 4. itly , . i. ('t/.1�� • j.y'7y� ':rr l * i 4'7 \ ., • ;; ,� \iy �'SS77} r y S�« KW* f x 2i,, •Y'S / �.i :>,., / 1 ;.1 1 S ,. .ate ` •s.`. '-,'� j. 1 •K � . -,•4..!`•i r''n�S .�s elh''l; ' y'I�f ,a / js�s tip �'f , .I nr i 1 'S ,k' r '7<? � 4A ri, !% a9 A �. ' rJ a, F • I. •,:7** f ' ') i- S' ` < r ; , •.r • r S ♦ .' s'I s L'Sa ati� l." .4..• t ..ti.. '.� 1`- r, " J y .. TY` j % % :' Si `+a rJ"_ r 4sp',r/r'X` ""1.'�. Al I L-� } II,, ` C r. �t ` •�"� 't sh> 3•}s�25s +ir•..�4'5+fi. '(Yj`r' q� 1 '!. , • F • ': r h' •��,' I t t. I • „} cif`• '.:\aqy ",1 y �. 3+ ' i4. P'fir (t�� / . 1 1lY „i �.. gyyro,... 1-.+' 0. .1 eo., '' i. w, r itv,,,,,,, ,..4.,,z,44t,,4, , IIyyR��,• IL • . , : .., ..„, ..s .,,..,,,......,...„. fr.4....,41.,,,i,__,,,...e.t.,•,, • __.. _ •...4. . ...e,.....16.v% 1 , I•1,, @ �J �L j� • r,.-.A---..-:-:-.*;-. #" a .4.,0"at - ./ 0:4 It ; , ak fi y '1'eCIO ca '� /3�'4y� y 1 -tl�.i.` y < . .�� =` - a spa rro+ .-aY,hfV ¢ 16 4-C • t,' .1� art r ly ya�-. i [''J •� LS I• ' v *VIi • y� I �\e \Y f� ii i ,,a `.,,.j '6 !1 v.- �:T �g �i+ ., ~ �i > I"' • a �- •. * Fa �{ {�;54�'"a .r0 ' M..iN'Ar"�.8 �' ..r A I .I fF C Rl. ' � `` kfy. \ . L\ 5., S.i.4/!1'1' a .� �.t<��ru1YY .... r! x.. Y is.. _. +... .•, s (?lf L, ' �.�YID 1, lyams6tAs"Liy` 5^''y , .... 1.,...,, a la: I.-1!*:- -fkb,s\II I , ' S' ••.- • l' -...:Zr,„‘,..,.... Tit, i French drain installation, Roots may have been severed when J� -i.. installation occurred. -- -A....r ,_ • 4. - s. .r 0., 1h7/441 �r «r G J n ,7} }" ' • N r 6n . d Fy y ,,..1 •r_u•jl : .' -*Y r -' ' .e7 mot, ! ‹' ' r i �a�$ � '7'�.- [aGt 9![r ' , - to r' Fai . } ,r ,,.1 •�� rIp(�C } V_A�. r4 i-- \ .vil ..... li � � • a p i � � _ •P‘t I:. ""- 4::4114111toilit. . . ::- . . �/is r* .. e�l f'c If:rt.!.r r'« S ‘^i1.1ste!vtp• ` t .. ,1 ` 1 • 4 a i 1 gale v �Rr i : W 1`# �/ t - W 44 y-;$� } .ram . ' /., ks,•� � - • _ „'i re ..., , ..,_ , . 0 ' pe414".471-'.....).:1WI, -...: . it / N4 ' • , #110 1'.7;.4g.:;;IYALAI CY., f ^. .1. .,'II_:. ' tka': f " v.,., �? 'A. - -.. ",�1: '�F�•• � �:�r +fit. a-}}a �.- �y�,,t 7 .t r � o' • 7" 'r r ;..r 41 •�,,'i�Ay,��y�^- '�'1� ��5` ;a. `IL':'Kv.." ..�", 1y.,�.>fsyY;''..1-- '~' >a� Y y2"7►��. .f'/��' • t r }} i'r. r !. • icy ,..^.. + a ,.r v r"•� •rb p'y ICI ��" " T"r •/. yr�.[' . o- !irit,.•' . r i .rY ''r«7;' Sri.: „ 7�•w:' i. ffiii ..w :.fj' -t • 4y y J A`" .♦ 1es Y / �q • r :,, rwid �_^..... .i- ..Y.r+ sSy , , ., •t �*�.♦ys�% `} a1 '• . .r(p •\ )i ♦. .. "w ' �,� 1 �.J I .J'.� t F N( •�If•-.. .., ,j .. '• i11`` i, `Arr,• • •\,,7"�+(♦ { t -4. !LT',�� .��,d t r 7 • !•4y.r,. 4r.', , /y4." , e,•4„„,_ . ,,,;. . a• ♦r^r I7Y, '`y ..A'K`( yy .1: r • L. `+ "•yamr- ,Y►•, `'' 'y„ /"yti�"va. -h • 1, 1 'K' ,�•1Aj. a�a Ti' • f '7� � - a'y � yI�a• , • 'f' {.ty y.t � +' �, � • , 0 ter. ` i�_> si -Act..., .'4 "A f :47/ a_.'.i , �e 'S. 7�'� �I''�•` ate' +'w.# •,. 1' ay.,.�]c t, i r'�41 `*4 r .. �tii ?('x •� C �y�!+'`o/�v '� �'r -frc 7J -7�t� vL jam! xy j ' • q� ' ., 1 /yam"` .t c, - p... - 7: • ^'i' •...- �. �~�Yr. w a' .`Y , i7i1$ r,/��lrF µ ti. F!,}r ^ K r.- t FfK t � -*may Iti, 40,47t . I d. 4 91 :,,,..: . .. 4 I ^^ ' ....1 - • ..1� ;f:,- '7 r' �. •1' 'd'►�'` (,y•',e.�,.'.11 'r y 94 r -�'t.'n `y1,: t:.. .?� v...r ' v l •, i! I i 1. /: .. ri -.r r ttt1 :x +..L" 1i'•a.f-es_• . ,,� rt:`' =LbX 17� -" 1"` '•" V h r. •• L 4.,. . • cfr.'.•r • r-g- ,R , „ ti4•q� f �rA, r ,..7- ! , T f• `,.% `t7 'ram 71wt K , '' v.-5;1 _� 'jj ?? , y r 1'' t . , a t7- n ♦alsi'a, r w 'f£ .. .r .1r.11 ..,`' 1rj • - r'.t i , - * n4 ;T 7M1_ it ,•4r, rYs1 f',_ ..%w r. r A i� v M ♦ i t; 'f 1.14 Fr. tL 1+... r —~ a4 •RYA-. • 4. . ` N . J 'L ,.•. . ✓—Lr rr31 � � ♦ , .C- ♦ � ' wyp '44' et.: f' .''r{r �.v+ g . t✓' . r. tt f ,. -y'f aSJI )a ,r 'Y_ a ' i ..k ,, f rT yr , ''„'t• L 6f. . r 4 %SrcJJ4Y, .I ii• u y`�+" -.. Y : a• a.Va :: .` . .. '. I r ... •. � { 7F ~rr�,ta}! a t $A:` t '''.+. ` . .^$: . ,Y ,,.,r, v 'IV** • 71 "' '' ,fi�I)♦•, of ` � 1 7';�. ,�^n..r.r'r /"' 'i r lr ' ,i4, . t14;, 4A. ¢• A'+. 'y g� •.--;„ ,,�1. r~ j4 i• 1• '�•� T r •.,A, y�' - i/ 'l i f t a 4"_ .y. i'yyJ :{'t<' i t"' y .q,+N�.a N .�``iR. ' .'�, '` r, Te t 1 - . i - '.y ts.N7w. r/•�k'Y•.S l r. Sr,I. Y ; syy♦. �♦-1 v �t♦�J• •�,�`y• "" 6 .ig,, '' ` ' i ,�{.. r4'Y 7f. 4 ' N't ' v• , A 7. • '' ..•+�• :w;t '♦. ,'R (�, }. }ter r tt•. E- -PAwArIlik_- ''L`�, { >4• . ��• �� .`a , r y�• • .. IE 5.-��C— . ,,{ lam�,t['�y�y-.' x!y { .. lfA.,AA t�y,�y� _ r ..�i,P�• w7. 4 h7 .i .-Mt-s'•.. 'L1:- xrt• 7'}i_y.'ls,ffi.lr 't Y''• •• '�'S�"Sr �' ■9Y�. 1 .1..&" 1'• a L1LL3Rr s_' -Y... Risk Categorization likelihood Failure Impact Failure&Impact Consequences Target Cond(don(s) (from Mena]) (target number Tree part u ordesaipdonJ of concern :n a n > u c Risk 'o 2 A E o E d d �, / m 0 g rating E c o I.E u o u m = c x d —a _°c P u fham 11__ ( n. a > .a S .n 7 > Z h in Morns2) 1s .-Ltdev' Ce.rvkc 'QRceY' dekx.Ck 61)ee" ' - 2(x c: vetllc.leS {:it\t , -e 2cth-s ILAt+l k ! 7'' 1Li Seuer (i.) , 1-4'o.c r-f l'G ,- b-r,;el rukS )ns-?z lied Matrix I.Likelihood matrix. I 1 Likelihood likelihood of Impact of Failure Very low Low Medium High Imminent Unlikely Somewhat likely Likely Very likely Probable Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat likely Likely Possible Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Somewhat likely Improbable Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Unlikely Matrut2 Risk rating matrix. LJkellhood of Consequences of Failure Failure&Impact Negligible Minor Significant Severe Very likely Low Moderate High Extreme Likely Low Moderate High High Somewhat likely Low Low Moderate Moderate North Unlikely Low Low Low Low Notes,explanations,descriptions 9% i 1,..... ,, .. . Mon options i. 441/iiLY Ck.ai.ck itkt in:iteaLTI t,,c(rt 4re4, '-C-1.0 - 0 1 1kf.12i' Residual risk 2. :r- (\4:. (OC C C?\A Residual risk 3. Residual risk 4• Residual risk Overall tree risk rating Low 0 ModeratV High 0 Extreme 0 Overall residual risk None 0 Low 0 Moderate 0 High 0 Extreme 0 Recommended inspection interval Data 0 Final 0 Preliminary Advanced assessment needed bNo❑Yes-Type/Reason Inspection limitations l3None OVisibility ❑Access OVines ❑Root collar buried Describe LAY'( 2 O- St' 5 VV14..1(2i- This darasbcot was produced by the International Society ofArbadndture(ISA)—2017 Page 2 of 2 IS11. Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form Client i-r l,L 2 17 Date 0 15/?v Time i 5Z pla, Address/Tree location RI 5L S tt.: C-Ic:r i en P Tree no. I Sheet L of Z. Tree species 2f'd (Xi{._ dbh .--t-' 3i,r. Height 55 I Crown spread dia. Nam' Assessors) Jane•`^"' (% scc:.i. .r ci4tlLET)L) Tools used Ci-il i;.c i fen Tap-c Time frame Target Assessment Target zone a = c i Occupancy ti S i-rare I n c Target description Target protection a x z_-occasional u z oi E. tpn gti 3-frequent I IT g ge 1s, 4-constant a E t[n 1 Uphit(p6 ,. 1U )0 9 nu nc 3 4 C, Site Factors History of failures 7x`<-SACi2 �rti�i tJ',b Topography Flat❑Slope❑ % Aspect Site changes None Grade change Site clearing Changed soil hydrologyFPRoot cuts❑ Describe • ' r._ 'Dl:j ' s+'v Sex//r.hr:r, Soil conditions Limited volumerBFSaturated❑ Shallow Compacted Pavement over roots5' '7'i % DescribeTt-t,' 14 icl, Li yft'L'i. Prevailing wind direction Common weather Strong winds-ice❑ Snow 0 Heavy rainj ; Describe Sl.,.a Tree Health and Species Profile • Vigor Low'D Normal 0 High 0 Foliage None(seasonal) None(dead)❑ Normal_% Chlorotic_% Necrotic_% Pests/Biotic Abiotic Species failure profile Bra nches-'Trunk❑ Roots❑' Describe F7iT.nCi. fia•trc.-. IS tiIi 511r.•1;..1 j •^.r c were Ctx* Load Factors eres..,, 3:c:es GJ,yfc I(4,1iark. Wind exposure Protected❑ Partial❑ Full❑:Wind funneling❑ Relative crown size Small Medium Larger.l5P Crown density Sparse- 'Normal 0 Dense❑ Interior branches Fewt 1-Normal 0 Dense 0 Vines/Mistletoe/Moss 0 1 Recent or expected change In load factors Tree Defects and Conditions Affecting the Likelihood of Failure —Crown and Branches— Unbalanced crown 0 LCR 2)` % Cracks 0 Lightning damage 0 Dead twigs/brenches{d' .9l %overall Max.dia. -1 Codominant CI Included bark 0 Broken/Hangers Number Max.dla. _ -4t' Weakattarhments l` t),`r.d l..'.h " I Ct'y i Cavit/Nest hole%tint. Over extended branches Previous branch failures fr]- Similar branches present;O-- Pruning history Dead/Missing bark 0 Cankers/Galls/Burls Cl Sapwood damage/decay 0 Crown cleaned 0 Thinned 0 Raised 0 Reduced 0 Topped ❑ Lion-tailed ❑ Conks 0 Heartwood decay 0 Flush cuts 0 Other Response growth Itit.,s.......( Condition(s)of concern 'Sr c,Itcy-Jr t l •„�i s Part Size Fall Distance Part Size Fall Distance Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate❑-Signifiant 0 Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate❑ Significant Likelihood of failure Improbable❑ Possible 0 Probable O Imminent , Likelihood of failure Improbable Possible Probable 0 Imminent —Trunk— —Roots and Root Collar— Dead/Missing bark 0 Abnormal bark texture/color 0 Collar buried/Not visible 0 Depth Stem girdling 0 Codominant stems 0 Included bark 0 Cracks 0 Dead 0 Decay 0 Conla/Mushroorns 0 Sapwood damage/decay 0 Cankers/Galls/Burls 0 Sap ooze 0 Ooze 0 Cavity❑%arc. Lightning damage❑ Heartwood decay 0 Conks/Mushrooms❑ Cracks 0 Cut/Damaged roots Distance from trunk (✓ Cavity/Nest hole %circ. Depth Poor taper❑ Root plate lifting Cl Soil weakness 0 Lean Corrected? Response growth UerySIw=, i 'e-. tc hn c-fr (t- Response growth J Condition(s)of concern beC-(•V%f! Condition(s)of concern Part Size Fall Distance Part Size lC)l Fall Distance c Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate❑ Significant 0 Load on defect N/A❑ Minor 0 Moderate�Signifiant 0 Likelihood of failure Improbable❑ Possible 0 Probable Imminent Likelihood of failure Improbable❑ PossibleIPProbable ❑ Imminent 0 Page I of 2 City of Tigard TIGA- Tree Risk Assessment Form Hazard Rating. L . Probability + The Target + Size of = Overall Risk of Failure Area Defective Part Rating Recommended Hazard Tree Abatement Procedures: Xr1C)t^x-,(I h uJ,i 11.A.-I--,'c cc+I'(AA j 11 C._ I1 E)..:1 I OC Cc +GI-A, V` \44,.o f N P,)1 I `i-r--60e i-o 'l-{,'c i 0t Property Address: 1 Z1� i)LV (1C4 rr_4 P1 pi Location: ❑ Public rivate ❑ Right-of-Way Protected Tree: 0 Yes ('No Tree Species: C_-4 (Ck C -47 Diameter at Breast Height(DBH): 2 Li 3/() Tree Height: 5. Crown Spread: 145 Tree Part Subject of Evaluation: Cii—b-..)r\ / ('Cc 11 f;!. ,L.` CU'lLs ' CC: f�"CJC Diameter of Subject Tree Pan 3/j p 6 c r e / I 2", L€ a{rt:, tpL i e r rt `I lr�'Distance to Target of Subject Tree Part: 6� l-c: "* I � t Length of Subject Tree Part: `i L Cu o O c to . e:e\'�we 'k---ze Cr (I,A it£ Target: k)r htC Ay,5 "f t,c.`tC 11--)r-(•-c*C' Occupancy of Target: 0 Occasional Use 0 Intermittent Use ❑ Frequent Use (ifiZonstant Use Date of Evaluation: 1+Ill 2_L' j Tree Risk Assessor: �iM,(,( 1 [p2'n''/rl.( �/1 i .1 (/ fj\ ISA Number: ?i - �:)/ -- iI- Tree Risk Assessor Signature: *Fill out this and supplemental rating form completely and attach:1)photos of the tree;2)an aerial photo showing the location of the tree on the subject property;and 3)a supplemental tree risk assessment report more fully describing whether the definition of hazard tree has been met and,if necessary,recommended hazard tree abatement procedures. Appendix 1 1144 t*te di 41,%i 0.4 MONARCH Park 217 Oak Tree Removals and Mitigation Plan 9-22-2020 3roposal 11-11i-2020 . . ',.•1 .0y.44?' , ,,,k.0,,,rirri.3, ; :.,' .-I,, :',..11.e.• , ,- ,- 1:043 ' ,$,',. .:7,1t1e ,:fli ..i . . /..i:-.;-• , r.:'.!:.. ..--.. . , - I i, i 741.-i.. i "'f• VIT'•':. 1" 4 r ... r.- .•• , • - ... • ,• - F.r...- . ..-•:-:.-- .,- ...::...,40 .,..,.. -... ::.:r..7...,... , , ...v....1i . •......z.,,,, • ,.! •••!se,,,..'..-4.9L,..- -.*- i: . ' • - "'ON.: - Vityk,2.A .„4:Ikeigc,k.; '4. .P.-11/.7.4,-. "'ci 4..- • - vat••••;) "•3 Witfje:.'• .::: ..- '" -.1.I'l -i.-..• 1.1.; ri.-! P'''' 74.i1121 .1•,Y1:S. 4,• .5. . . W. ,- •-.. . . . . ,, "••4' ••-.P 74C "ri'. a.'••"-•P••'? evA.- . - °. ." • :i.: " • . -•-1-....1.. ".•'' "ir ...i%;:f;;.a.e. 1;;;-2: - . ' '„Jr.' . ,...." - :. •...• ' '..;' :;•'•'"";.4#4.3 .1\7.‘,1 ' itoriki---;i-•...;-t•-4"....---.-.1..r.-....,...."....-4...;-...y, ---........„?, -.......IVi .; ' .. . r ' - ..N'.1 *-'t.' '1'.e•::..i.•-,"?'•:'':."'•''.;:j.4',(40;;P4i:.41 '' • ' •-• :: '' ' ''" ' : '•'.r.. ' -;.ii•'-' ''',4'14. 7< V1.4'.!1 . 'R' ' • '7.:;.e.":4,' NI 'i: . '':.-' •- "4 I A,.., ,...., \ • f ... i ' . . - - ..: -. -' _ - 4144-:: .,.,(•••• - %. '••• -4.0". , . . • '' r ' - '•. .'.4, ..A, • '-. ' .:;.;•arlir,,Ek . -:. i,,, -,-4 -. .1.-...c-..L , 1 . _ ,.,.y.rirv-1- , •:i.,,vaPort44,' ?'";14 :'' -5''''t -7N% ‘' i"- . 1 ' --- :' • - ..'"'`: ' r", .'",•:2;,`"4.5:. 'ef-4./..P%.. ,, ,..A-':-.7 ,,,,-,t.t: November 12.2020 November 12,2020 Quercus rubra 113#3 Quercus rubra I D#3 Northern Red Oak Northern Red Oak ..• • . . , c . t • ,- ' • if.). 0 . .• ,. ,... 'R':•• , ,..5 --•' .. ,3 t., -; IA -- it",t. • ..„. -A .C.T.' fS •• 4/-‘ . ".- C"t IS . • f , •.4' V.1. .G"•' . • • •S-1. y . f .f.%...:;:g. . 1••••.."*T. *'"/•', _ -- . " ..." ...'' • 'r'•.9.:•-,. . S'' "‘q.`44;•1•;.•,`.14 ..:- .!•'V q,04'. ire • ',-,--_" !.:-..k., •.',',ird,, `fi? :,...,,,......fY41-,4V,:-:-, • -. .•iy.t.-,1?, ' .• ..... .),.-.t..t. . ..-4•,-,-...' •.-,4. . .. - -,.. .-- - •,....,..1... %• .1.'.•••.,:i!' S.,-i*.•-:-/..;.- A..:-:.5. 7:;,...,E,.. 0; .... .i. :,k, .......---41, f --:- . i -...... .....•,- l•-• ' ....' , , ;•,4.'' ,'.7q.., S-'''-:;•iic. - i':.' - . 4.:.47-tedr,D ••••• ''Ir .- li,x. - 4'd :'01!. 'i.ft, '-ii, .41... - . ...Mil Y • ..ee ,..., 1 •....,-...:!- ' .4. '' ''?,,,'‘ 4-24;°- ;.'..',.i.. , r•e".1 . ...•41:5;L!.:' ‘k. .•€' 6.0..0. ,,41...A ' " • • . . ..4. ,n,".,,,, .;,6 , '",,,... , fkA,j, t-S„.gte,„,,,,;,..,...tp.b.t.r.;,...dor4..,r...1.3;le, :o.egon.u.sorao•reresurw'rr •G.Q091k.es.me,:Pc,n.s 0;w.Strt CitOr<90..US.SCONK,V Retriov'&1 Hen-)w-il Proposal#193258 Page 4 .% ., MONARCH Park 217 Oak Tree Removals and Mitigation Plan 9-22-2020 roposal 11-16-2020 Y . :k P fh 1 'i : fit t t ,. w( 4.e '`•%`ten <'` 1 Y tr` r?' k 4 : w ,Y v . .. .. • t .,, .• ti t,. r :� ` 1 L . '. 7�1 i4, ‘ .•/1�-A ,• :.a � . i 4J - 4 ) .wC^ . �•VrFa [y � "� r. • ; f �:Si1 . t�iAYam+ r c oftiX5. - J .1...6.. �+ t, K4ir4v ia. ` `ma _,D h „,* ... L1. • • Ty _ilk ` _a__t September 22,2020 September 22,2020 September 22,2020 Quercus rubra ID#1 Quercus rubra ID#1 Quercus rubra ID#2 Northern Red Oak Northern Red Oak Northern Red Oak f J air \`", _ ^ S7Ctr. ! t ' !� iJ- QY1`��i '-! t t�fJ��1e447C�i ., .r ! f ,.1/r' i 1' aj(�Rt, T 09e/n-r.Ine.PAe053,0 beer•State oCe4,U9 Gewx;cm Su,ry ••• • �•it". .. • .- .. .G_. kip Ab .CI.. ay . . ... 0 .w._. Removal Removal Removal Page; Proposal#193258