Report (2) I GC55 ot 8 A-14-
OFFICE COPY
COMcheck Software Version 4.L1.0
irp
i
Envelope Compliance Certificate
Project Information .4,,AV i
Energy Code: 90.1 (2016)Standard JAN 3 0 2020
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House
Location: Tigard,Oregon y t �• /�.
Climate Zone: 4c �� r '� >a` c+ �� I
Project Type: Alteration BCUIY=�4J'� ' i'f)V4+6��t'''N
Construction Site: Owner/Agent: Designer/Contractor:
15555 SW 98th Avenue The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter- Antonio Johnson
Tigard,OR 97224 Day Saints MFIA Consulting Engineers
2007 SE Ash Street
Portland, OR 97214
503.234.0548
antonio.johnson@mfia-eng,com
Building Area Floor Area
1-Religious Building:Nonresidential 18900
Envelope Assemblies
Envelope TBD: No envelope assemblies specified
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880 Tigard Meeting House COM Page 1 of 12
Check.cck
COMcheck Software Version 4.1.1.0
Mechanical Compliance Certificate
Project Information
Energy Code: 90.1 (2016)Standard
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House
Location: Tigard,Oregon
Climate Zone: 4c
Project Type: Alteration
Construction Site: Owner/Agent: Designer/Contractor:
15555 SW 98th Avenue The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter- Antonio Johnson
Tigard,OR 97224 Day Saints MFIA Consulting Engineers
2007 SE Ash Street
Portland,OR 97214
503.234.0548
antonio.johnson@mfia-eng.com
Mechanical Systems List
Quantity System Type&Description
1 F-4
Heating:1 each-Central Furnace,Gas,Capacity=66 kBtu/h
Fan System: Unspecified
SYSTEM COMPLIANCE EXEMPTION APPLIES
Exemption:Extensive ancillary requirements.
1 CU/AH-1
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 228 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
Proposed Efficiency:11.00 EER(Refer to mech.plans for proposed IPLV),
Required Efficiency: 10.500 EER +11.8 IEER)
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/AH-2
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 228 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
Proposed Efficiency:11.00 EER(Refer to mech.plans for proposed IPLV),
Required Efficiency: 10.500 EER +11.8 IEER)
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/AH-3
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 115 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/F1
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 60 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/F-2
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 60 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 2 of 12
Check.cck
Quantity System Type&Description
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/F-3
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 36 kBtu/h.Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/F-4
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 24 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/F-5
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 60 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
1 CU/F-6
Cooling:Condensing Unit,Capacity 60 kBtu/h,Condenser Air-Cooled
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
PLANT COMPLIANCE REQUIRED.
Mechanical Compliance Statement
Compliance Statement: The proposed mechanical alteration project represented in this document is consistent with the building
plans,specifications,and other calculations submitted with this permit application.The proposed mechanical systems have been
designed to meet the 90.1 (2016)Standard requirements in ersion 4.1.1.0 and to comply with any applicable
mandatory requirements listed in the Inspection Checklist.
staltieMEMit 041,6 S OC-fr L 4 a! Ioctizocto
Name•Title Signature Date
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880 Tigard Meeting House COM Page 3 of 12
Check.cck
COMcheck Software Version 4.1.1.0
gi Inspection Checklist
Energy Code: 90.1 (2016) Standard
irril
Requirements: 100.0% were addressed directly in the COMcheck software
Text in the "Comments/Assumptions" column is provided by the user in the COMcheck Requirements screen. For each
requirement, the user certifies that a code requirement will be met and how that is documented, or that an exception
is being claimed. Where compliance is itemized in a separate table, a reference to that table is provided.
Section
& Re ID Plan Review Complies? i Comments/Assumptions
4.2.2, Plans, specifications, and/or ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
6.4.4.2.1, calculations provide all information EDoes Not
6.7.2 with which compliance can be �fC C�y .�
[PR2]' determined for the mechanical ❑Not Observable IICt
systems and equipment and Not Applicable
document where exceptions to the
standard are claimed.Load
calculations per acceptable
engineering standards and ,
handbooks.
4.2.2, Plans, specifications,and/or :❑Complies Requirement will be met.
8.4,1.1, calculations provide all information -❑Does Not
8.4.1.2, with which compliance can be Location on plans/spec: NA
8.7 determined for the electrical systems :Not Observable
[PR612 and equipment and document where ❑Not Applicable
exceptions are claimed.Feeder
connectors sized in accordance with
approved plans and branch circuits
— sized for maximum drop of 3%.
6.7.2.4 Detailed instructions for HVAC ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[PR5)1 systems commissioning included on ODoes Not
the plans or specifications for projects
>=50,000 ft2. ❑Not Observable NIA-
I$Not Applicable
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
I High Impact(Tier 1) 4l Medium Impact(Tier 2) 3.!Low Impact(Tier 3) j
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 4 of 12
Check.cck
Section
# Footing 1 Foundation Inspection Complies? Comments/Assumptions
& Reg.ID ---
6.4.3.7 Freeze protection and snow/ice ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does not apply.
[FO913 melting system sensors for future ❑Does Not
connection to controls. [Not Observable IN
—
INNot Applicable
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
High Impact(Tier 1) 2 Medium Impact(Tier 2) 3s'Low Impact(Tier 3) 1
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880 Tigard Meeting House COM Page 5 of 12
Check.cck
Section I Mechanical Rough-In i Plans Verified Field Verified
# Inspection Value Value Complies? Comments/Assumptions
& Req.ID •
6.4.1.4, HVAC equipment efficiency Efficiency Efficiency:_ Complies See the Mechanical Systems list
6.4.1.5 verified. Non-NAECA HVAC ❑Does Not for values.
[ME1I2 equipment labeled as meeting �—
90.1. ❑Not Observable
❑Not Applicable
6.4.3.4.1 Stair and elevator shaft vents ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
(ME3]3 have motorized dampers that ❑Does Not does not apply.
automatically close.
Pilot Observable
Titiot Applicable
6.4.3.4.2, Outdoor air and exhaust systems ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
6.4.3.4.3 have motorized dampers that ❑Does Not
[ME4p automatically shut when not in Location on plans/spec:
use and meet maximum leakage ❑Not Observable .NA cr1
rates. Check gravity dampers .. :-:- a ®Not Applicable GJ t
where allowed.
6.4.3.4.5 Enclosed parking garage ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
[ME39]3 ventilation has automatic ❑Does Not does not apply.
contaminant detection and
capacity to stage or modulate ❑Not Observable
fans to 50%or less of design UNot Applicable
capacity.
6.4.3.4.4 Ventilation fans>0.75 hp have ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME5]3 automatic controls to shut off fan ❑Does Not
when not required. ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
:� NA
—Not Applicable
6.4.3.8 Demand control ventilation ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME6J' provided for spaces>500 ft2 and ❑Does Not
>25 people/1000 ft2 occupant Location on plans/spec:
density and served by systems ❑�,y.Not Observable NA
with air side economizer,auto LyNot Applicable
modulating outside air damper
control,or design airflow>3,000
cfm.
6.5.3.2.1 DX cooling systems >=75 kBtu/h ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
[ME4012 (>= 65 kBtu/h effective 1/2016) ❑Does Not does not apply.
and chilled-water and
evaporative cooling fan motor hp h -•` a ' .. s `A, `❑Not Observable See the Mechanical Systems list
>=1 designed to vary supply r s 1 '* k£. Not Applicable for values.
fan airflow as a function of load ., ,
and comply with operational ,, ;_`,. f ,. '
requirements. ' " :) ; �(`
6.4.4.1.1 Insulation exposed to weather ,; , '( *. (fi]Com lies
[ME7]3 protected from damage. . ' : *` '❑ p Requirement will be met.
Insulation outside of the at t" ., Does Not
+ � ,: Location on Ions/s ec:
conditioned space and associated "•' � e .^ -'t *❑Not Observable M6.0,See specifications
with cooling systems is vapor l „:; . ❑Not Applicable
retardant. -
_ -3:.v:"a: . :.k j `w 2AiJrt u . 4
6.4.4.1.2 HVAC ducts and plenums R-_ R-_ ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
IME8]z insulated per Table 6.8.2. Where ❑Does Not
ducts or plenums are installed in Location on plans/spec:
or under a slab, verification may p❑�Not Observable No new ductwork
need to occur during Foundation Io Not Applicable
Inspection.
6.4.4.1.3 HVAC piping insulation thickness. _in. _in. ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME9J2 Where piping is installed in or ❑Does Not does not apply.
under a slab,verification may
need to occur during Foundation ❑Not Observable
Inspection, 0-Not Applicable i
I 1 High Impact(Tier 1) 2 Medium Impact(Tier 2) 3 ,,Low Impact(Tier 3)
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880 Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 6 of 12
Check.cck
Section Mechanical Rough-In Plans Verified j Field Verified
# Inspection Value Value Complies? Comments/Assumptions
& Req.ID'
6.4.4.1.4 Thermally ineffective panel ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME41]3 surfaces of sensible heating ❑Does Not
panels have insulation>= R-3.5. ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
Does not apply
NNot Applicable
6.4.4.2.1 Ducts and plenums having ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
(ME10)2 pressure class ratings are Seal Does Not
Class A construction. Location on plans/spec:
❑Not Observable No new ductwork
Not Applicable
6.8.1-14, Electrically operated DX-DOAS ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
6.8.1-15 units meet requirements per ❑Does Not does not apply.
(ME110]2 Tables 6.8.1-14 or 6.8.1-15.
❑Not Observable
Not Applicable
6.4 4.2,2 Ductwork operating >3 in.water ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME11]3 column requires air leakage ❑Does Not
testing.
❑Not Observable No plans/spec:
New Ductwork
New
ct$Not Applicable
6.5.2.3 Dehumidification controls ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME19]3 provided to prevent reheating, ❑Does Not
retooling, mixing of hot and cold Location on plans/spec:
airstreams or concurrent heating Not Observable NA
and cooling of the same pNot Applicable
airstream.
6.5.2.4.1 Humidifiers with airstream ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
EME68P mounted preheating jackets have EDoes Not does not apply.
preheat auto-shutoff value set to
activate when humidification Is ❑Not Observable
not required. NNot Applicable
6.5.2.4.2 Humidification system dispersion ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
(ME69]3 tube hot surfaces in the ❑Does Not 'does not apply.
airstreams of ducts or air-
handling units insulated>=R- :Not Observable
0.5. grNot Applicable
F.
16.5.2.5 Preheat coils controlled to stop ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME70]3 heat output whenever ❑Does Not
mechanical cooling, including Location on plans/spec:
economizer operation, is active. ❑Not Observable NA
Not Applicable
6.5.2.6 Units that provide ventilation air JComplies Exception:Requirement
[ME106J3 to multiple zones and operate in ❑Does Not does not apply.
conjunction with zone heating
and cooling systems are [Not Observable i,.G c o r
prevented from using heating or ❑Not Applicable 'T tLa-
heat recovery to warm supply air
above 60°F when representative
building loads or outdoor air
temperature indicate that most
zones demand cooling.
6.5.4.7 Chilled-water cooling coils ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME107]3 provide a 15°F or higher ❑Does Not does not apply.
temperature difference between
1 leaving and entering water ❑Not Observable
temperatures and a minimum of PNot Applicable
I 57°F leaving water temperature
I at design conditions '
'`1!High Impact(Tier 1) 2, Medium Impact(Tier 2) 13,1 Low Impact(Tier 3) -.1
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 7 of 12
Check.cck
Section j Mechanical Rough In Plans Verified Field Verified 1 y
inspection Value Value Complies. Comments/Assumptions
ins
& Req.ID( ��
6.5,3.3 Multiple zone VAV systems with ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME42)3 DDC of individual zone boxes Does Not does not apply.
have static pressure setpoint ❑Not Observable
reset controls. Location on plans/spec:
Not Applicable ,No VAV Systems
See the Mechanical Systems list
for values.
6.5.4.2 HVAC pumping systems with >_ • Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME25]3 3 control values designed for ❑Does Not does not apply.
variable fluid flow(see section
details). ❑Not Observable
I):711Not Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79)3 water piping sized according to ❑Does Not
design flow rate and total annual ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation(Table NA
6.5.4.6). NNot Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to ❑Does Not
design flow rate and total annual ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation (Table NA
6.5.4.6). Not Applicable I;
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to ❑Does Not
design flow rate and total annual Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation(Table ❑Not Observable NA
6.5.4.6). Not Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met,
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to ❑Does Not
design flow rate and total annual ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation(Table NA
6.5.4.6). ' Not Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to Does Not
design flow rate and total annual ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation (Table NA
6.5.4.6). plNot Applicable
6.5.4
Chilled-water and condenser OComplies
(ME7 ] water
design fling ate and total annual ❑Not Observable irement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized accordingto
Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation(Table NA
6.5.4.6). tifi Not Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to ODoes Not
design flow rate and total annual ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation (Table NA
6.5.4.6). 94Not Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to ❑Does Not
design flow rate and total annual Not Observable Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation(Table .❑ NA
6.5.4.6). [hfNot Applicable
6.5.4.6 Chilled-water and condenser ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME79]3 water piping sized according to ❑Does Not
design flow rate and total annual ❑Not Observable •Location on plans/spec:
hours of operation(Table NA
6.5.4.6). q1Not Applicable
6.5.6.1 Exhaust air energy recovery on ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME56]' systems meeting Tables 6.5.6.1- ❑Does Not does not apply.PP Y•
1, and 6.5.6.1-2. ❑Not Observable
ydNot Applicable
1!High Impact(Tier 1) 2 Medium Impact(Tier 2) r1 Low Impact(Tier 3)
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 8 of 12
Check.cck
Section Mechanical Rough-In Plans Verified Field Verified
& Re ID Inspection Value Value Complies? Comments/Assumptions
!6.5.7.2.1 Kitchen hoods >5,000 cfm have ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME32]2 make up air>=50%of exhaust ❑Does Not does not apply.
air volume.
❑Not Observable
Not Applicable
6.5.7.2.4 Approved field test used to ❑Complies Exception: Requirement
[ME49]3 evaluate design air flow rates ❑Does Not does not apply.
and demonstrate proper capture Not Observable
and containment of kitchen ❑
exhaust systems. Not Applicable
6.5.8.1 Unenclosed spaces that are ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
[ME30 heated use only radiant heat. ❑Does Not does not apply.
❑Not Observable
ONot Applicable
6.4.3.9 Heating for vestibules and air ❑Complies Exception:Requirement
[ME63]z curtains with integral heating ODoes Not does not apply.
include automatic controls that
shut off the heating system when ❑Not Observable
outdoor air temperatures>45F. Not Applicable
Vestibule heating and cooling
systems controlled by a
thermostat in the vestibule with
heating setpoint<=60F and
cooling setpoint>= 80F.
6.5.10 Doors separating conditioned ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[ME73]3 space from the outdoors have ❑Does Not
controls that disable/reset Location on plans/spec:
heating and cooling system when ❑Not Observable NA
open. �`Not Applicable 1
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
11 High Impact(Tier 1) 2;:I Medium Impact(Tier 2) I-3 Low Impact(Tier 3)
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 9 of 12
Check.cck
Section
# Rough-In Electrical Inspection Complies' Comments/Assumptions
& Re .ID
8.4.2 At least 50%of all 125 volt 15- and ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does not apply.
[EL10]2 20-Amp receptacles are controlled by ❑Does Not
an automatic control device. ONot Observable
of Applicable
8.4.3 New buildings have electrical energy ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does not apply.
[EL11j2 use measurement devices installed. ❑Does Not
Where tenant spaces exist,each
tenant is monitored separately.In [Not Observable
buildings with a digital control system .[a[Jot Applicable
the energy use is transmitted to to
control system and displayed
graphically.
10.4.1 Electric motors meet requirements ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[EL9]2 where applicable. ❑Does Not
❑Not Observable
Location on plans/spec: NA
Not Applicable
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact(Tier 1) 2 Medium Impact(Tier 2) 1 3 ,Low Impact(Tier 3)
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880_Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 10 of 12
Check.cck
Section
# Final Inspection i Complies? Comments/Assumptions
Si Reg
.ID
6.4.3.1.2 Thermostatic controls have a 5 °F omplies Requirement will be met.
[FI3]3 deadband. ❑Does Not r�� ,y�
❑Not Observable nAvUlrt'42V7��/
❑Not Applicable
6.4.3.2 Temperature controls have setpoint 'Complies Requirement will be met. I
[F120]3 overlap restrictions. Does Not SQEc5
•
❑Not Observable i" -C'411
❑Not Applicable
6.4.3.3.1 HVAC systems equipped with at least ']Complies Requirement will be met.
[F121]3 one automatic shutdown control. ❑Does Not
❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec: NA
❑Not Applicable % &. 9PerS
6.4.3.3.Z,•Setback controls allow automatic KComplies Requirement will be met.
[F122]3 "restart and temporary operation as ❑Does Not
required for maintenance. ON Observable Location on plans/spec:.-� � C
NA
❑Not Applicable -4" �wvty IPer-.S '
6.4.3.6 When humidification and ❑Complies Requirement will be met.
[F16]3 dehumidification are provided to a ODoes Not
zone,simultaneous operation is Location on plans/spec: NA
prohibited.Humidity control prohibits ❑Not Observable
the use of fossil fuel or electricity to IX1ot Applicable
produce RH >30%in the warmest
zone humidified and RH <60%in the
coldest zone dehumidified.
6.7.2.1 Furnished HVAC as-built drawings :VIComplies Requirement will be met.
[FI7]3 submitted within 90 days of system ❑Does Not
acceptance. SPEGS -
❑Not Observable
❑Not Applicable
6.7.2.2 Furnished O&M manuals for HVAC IgComplies Requirement will be met.
[Fl8p systems within 90 days of system ❑Does Not
acceptance. S?° ,
ONot Observable
❑Not Applicable
6.7.2.3 An air and/or hydronic system '❑Complies Exception: Requirement does not apply.
[Fi9]' balancing report is provided for HVAC ❑Does Not CC)systems serving zones >5,000 ft2 of 'ONot Observable S(1 .571514—
conditioned area.
glNot Applicable
6.7.2.4 HVAC control systems have been ❑Complies Requirement will be met. 1
[FI10]' tested to ensure proper operation, ❑Does Not S
calibration and adjustment of controls. ❑Not Observable
Not Applicable
10.4.3 Elevators are designed with the ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does not apply.
[F124]2 proper lighting,ventilation power,and ❑Does Not
standby mode.
El Not Observable
Piot Applicable
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact(Tier 1) 2 IMedium Impact(Tier 2) r3 Low Impact(Tier 3)_
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880 Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 11 of 12
Check.cck
Project Title: Tigard 98th Avenue Meeting House Report date: 01/10/20
Data filename: G:\Bella Opus\9880 Tigard Meeting House\Energy Forms\9880_Tigard Meeting House COM Page 12 of 12
Check.cck